

Examples should be made
Whelp, if deterrence worked the prisons wouldn’t be overflowing. Most murderous bastards are not rational about it.
There is no touchy-feelying this one into anything remotely civilized.
Ah there it is, the rule of law is subject to the Law of the Jungle ethos.
‘They weren’t civilized, why should I be?’ I have explained this issue to toddlers through teens. That is not how it works.
Restitution vs retribution is not touchy-feely FFS. It’s basic ethics. We need more of that in grade school curriculum, along with history.






You are at the wrong station.
Please folks, don’t confuse justice with policing, or crime prevention.
Restitution, and in general a ‘fixing the wrongs’ approach to justice, is not about prevention, it is about clean up and repairs. How that is done is a whole discussion about details, but we are discussing principles at the moment.
Prevention: a healthy neighbourhood with embedded nurses, social workers, and active mental health services could have caught this kind of shit. Functional education system would have caught it. Also: see economics for causes, aka material conditions.
Punishment: well cruelty is the point, isn’t it? And you get to participate without guilt.
I don’t believe them getting shanked will deter or prevent other child abusers in any way. Different issue.