• 350 Posts
  • 735 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 30th, 2023

help-circle














  • The article goes down a deep rabbit hole on the idea of returning land to the original indigenous owners. It’s interesting, but then what? Eilish’s point was apparently missed as the article drifts. When the land is not returned (for whatever reason), there is a problem with bullying immigrants on the stolen land. Particularly when some of the “immigrants” are descendants of the original indigenous owners, which is the most perverse case the article neglects.

    My history knowledge on this is a bit spotty and sparse but IIRC California (or part of it) was originally part of Mexico. Perhaps Texas as well.


  • I’m with you. Works great for those living alone.

    But when there is a household w/3+ people, there is always someone who cannot resist playing the spineless pushover. Granny and gramps are living out their last decade; they will be damned if they give up convenient entertainment in their last stretch.

    So when one person in the household insists on these shitty overpriced subscriptions, then what? You can probably rightfully get the boot licker to pay the whole bill, but then do they have to watch alone? Or do others in the household freeload? It must be awkward in a lot of situations.



  • However, if you do think an upvote-based community is good as long as you’re the gatekeeper, you’re being lazy.

    Good tools enable us to be lazy. Whether I am am personally “lazy” is irrelevent. I tend to be motivated when the tools, protocols, and infra are well designed. OTOH, I become lazy when tools are lousy. I try to avoid poorly designed tools as much as possible.

    The solution is what you dismiss in the last paragraph as “too much effort”.

    Machines should work for humans. Not the other way around. If I were highly motivated to labor over blunt unsophisticated tools, every single invitee still has the extra labor of registration. To understand how that is a recipe for disaster, just look at MS Github. A vast majority of FOSS projects are jailed in Microsoft’s walled garden because all the users are too lazy to register more than one account.

    I do not have access to an unlimited WAN uplink. I am often offline for long stretches of time. So it’s not just a matter of investing time but money as well. A good infra doesn’t limit community builders to those with deep pockets.

    Your complaint that it’s overly isolated is entitlement to an audience’s attention.

    It’s not entitlement. It’s opportunity. Shutting off visibility is a missed opportunity for exposure. It’s another recipe for disaster.

    The point of federation is to share a community that you respect. You do not respect the community of this federation so you should not want to be connected with them.

    That’s another very blunt lever. Every community has adults and children; philosophical deep thinkers, and clowns; civil people and hotheads and trolls.


  • Concur w/most of what you said.

    Though I recall being shadow banned on Reddit and never getting transparency on Reddit. They have robots banning humans while humans are deceived into thinking their content is posted. Has that changed?

    On Lemmy, it’s despicable that removals are silent. But I think when viewing your own profile removed posts will have a red padlock or something subtle next to them. The Lemmy proponents would say “what client are you using? It’s your fault you’re using a client that does not signal you… Write your own client.” This is how they fend off criticism of the stock Lemmy client. It’s almost kind of somewhat fair enough because we probably want the Lemmy devs to focus on the server anyway. We have to think of that shitty javascript web client as a demo tool for testing. I actually use the garbage but that’s out of lack of existence of a decent non-JavaScript desktop client with local storage.

    The worst scenario: using kbin to post to a Lemmy community. When the post is removed, all traces of the content is silently destroyed and irrecoverable. You go to your own profile and it’s as if the post never existed. You suffer data loss of your own work.

    I have yet to seriously try piefed. But certainly kbin/mbin and Lemmy are a shitshow with no decent apps.