I have heard rumors of sexual assault allegations not being taken seriously in the PSL, but I have also seen another person saying they were just a wrecker …
I also heard that the structure is not really democratic.
I really do want to know what is really going on with the party.
Sources (that I have read and that also happen to relate to the topics above): Deleted them cuz they might have included names


The reaction from members cemented to me that the PSL isn’t a serious socialist group, but I really don’t know of any alternatives in the US. I did used to think they were the best option available for people in the great satan but now I wouldn’t recommend them to anyone, especially women.
Some serious communists need to start something, but I don’t imagine they can safely be a public group.
I don’t think Statesians should be worrying over what’s the best most revolutionary org in the us. None of the big names in the us have any real motion. If a nationwide organization in the us isn’t centered directly in indigenous and black liberation, then it’s not an org with any serious revolutionary potential. By that I don’t mean having a good party line or a good reading list, I mean that the org itself needs to be a manifestation of the struggle for indigenous and black liberation. The PSL, FRSO, or DSA are not that. As I understand it, the PSL is a group of about 2,000 people who do protests and no mutual aid. I have heard that they have good educational material though, which is cool. The BPP and AIM were the most successful groups in the us and the PSL is nothing like either.
I very much still think people should join orgs in order to connect with comrades, get training, and build up the organizational capacity of their communities. Join FRSO, DSA, even your local Food not Bombs, book clubs, or volunteer groups. Before I would’ve recommended PSL too. But if I had the opportunity to recommend someone in the us to join an org, it wouldn’t be the PSL now, especially, just like you said, if they were a woman. The reason isn’t because they’re not the perfect org, it’s specifically because the PSL is not a safe organizing space for fem presenting people. The org has covered up multiple cases of sexual abuse. I’m not judging the PSL for having to deal with sexual abuse, I’m judging them for how they’ve handled it.
Almost agreed, though FRSO has the major problems PSL has in addition to being far smaller despite existing for far longer, and erasing settler-colonialism, with their thought leader J. Sykes considering it “completed” and the Euro Settlers transcending settler status.
Yeah, I’m aware of FRSO’s reactionary stance on the settler-colonial question within the us. I wasn’t aware of sexual abuse within the organization. Did they not handle it well? Would you consider them a safe place for women to organize?
I can’t find a better source off the top of my head, but this Maoist split of FRSO criticizes their handling of sexual assault, and alleges they covered them up. I don’t think the United States is a safe place for women, period, and that extends to political organizations composed of people that live there, no matter their intentions. Therefore, whether or not an organization is “safe” is up to the woman involved, a value judgment they make. I’m a man, I’m cis, I cannot speak to relative levels of danger between the two orgs.
Between them, I have more experience talking to people in PSL than I do FRSO. FRSO is far smaller, and therefore also harder to find information on. The PSL’s problems with handling sexual assault are far easier to find partly because they are far larger and more public of an organization. That’s not to minimize them, in any way, but more to point that if I were a woman looking to organize, I’d have to look at what local organizations actually exist, including local branches of bigger organizations, and see how the local branches are.
The PSL’s problems are largely concentrated in the central leadership, less so in the rank and file, based on conversations with PSL members, and thus they are trying to fix the PSL from within by improving the democratic structures and reforming how discipline is handled. As a consequence, how dangerous they are is largely determined by who is in the local and how the local is run. Those remaining in the PSL are generally those that believe it can be reformed and grow into a better party, not those that believe it’s a party worthy of being a vanguard at the present moment.
The way I see it, there are 4 options to any communist looking to organize in the US: the PSL, the DSA (and joining or supporting a Marxist-Leninist caucus), starting or joining a local org from a study group, or a solidarity organization. Which to join depends on the state of local organizing and branches of PSL/DSA, and if you believe the PSL can actually be reformed, or if you’re better off trying to gain organizing experience through the DSA before starting your own org. Without a truly great ML organization in the empire, there’s no solid recommendation I can make.
All in all, I’m extremely frustrated that there’s no easy recommendation I can make for people. The only general recommendation I can make is to study seriously, and try to gain organizational experience, which can be gained from any organization. The US communist movement desparately needs a higher level of theoretical understanding, and a higher level of organizational skill. Therefore, the task of all communists is to improve our individual abilities and try to spread those to others. The orgs we choose to gain organizational skills from are those that present the best and safest opportunities locally, which is not something I can mechanically assume based on the status of empire-wide organizations.
I’d argue that these groups are necessary, if not to be the revolutionary vanguard, but to help the revolutionary vanguard. Also serve as necessary training grounds to the unpracticed.
The idea that nobody should put effort into a group because its not the vanguard when one doesn’t exist isn’t the best, in my opinion. (You did not say this, I should note clearly for anyone reading. You critique the focus on “big orgs” from marxists before supporting the participation in them. I only want to add to this line.)
BPP was part of a rainbow coalition and Fred Hampton really pushed for uniting all workers. Huey P. Newton also advocated for white people to start a “white panther party” to support the black panther party. If we are to help ensure the future of socialism, and the success of the vanguard party, it is critical that we organize now, and gain the experience of practice and further our studies with other comrades and other oppressed peoples. This building of power and class consciousness among the most oppressed people will help bring about the support necessary to meet the conditions of revolution. Should a moment arise in which you can’t justify being with a party, or it acts against revolution. One can simply focus their efforts on another organization.
Do not focus on a perfection, we most focus on agitating the people at the sharpest contradictions of the working class. We also, because of the time in which western marxists find themselves in a state of profound nihilism towards revolution(something I would say is a liberal tendency), must encourage our comrades to fight.
We act as though the capitalist state only grows in strength. Yet if one were to apply historical dialectics one will find that the contradictions only sharpen. The people grow only more oppressed. And the solution to the struggles of the working class grows even more obvious to even the uninitiated worker.
Without this “revolutionary optimism”, there is no chance for a revolution. Even with the perfect conditions.
Thank you for the reply. I appreciate it greatly.
Well said.