MrNobody@quokk.au to Whatever@quokk.auEnglish · 12 hours agoOnlyquokk.auimagemessage-square38linkfedilinkarrow-up1236arrow-down10
arrow-up1236arrow-down1imageOnlyquokk.auMrNobody@quokk.au to Whatever@quokk.auEnglish · 12 hours agomessage-square38linkfedilink
minus-squareLifeInMultipleChoice@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up6·edit-211 hours agoOkay so how many different meanings do we get? I’m counting 5 from a quick scan. That she is the only one who is allowed to kill goblins. That there is only one paladan in the group/world. She doesn’t kill anyone unless they are a goblin. She is the only one of the group whom informed the paladin that she does in fact kill goblins. She didn’t tell the rest of the group or anyone else, just the paladin Edit: added 5
minus-squareBuddahriffic@lemmy.worldlinkfedilinkarrow-up1·1 hour agoIf you put the only in different positions and then emphasise different words of the resulting sentence, you can get a lot of meanings.
minus-squarefunkless_eck@sh.itjust.workslinkfedilinkarrow-up3·9 hours ago Only she told the paladin that she kills goblins" Could be used to imply “except for the fact that…” “She thought her secrets were safe, only she told the paladin that she kills goblins. The paladin was quick to tell the King soon after.” In a different context, “they thought they were safe; only, they weren’t really”
minus-squareAppleTea@lemmy.ziplinkfedilinkarrow-up5·11 hours ago She [only] told the Paladin that she kills goblins Implies that the Paladin had some strong reaction to being told this She told the Paladin [only] that she kills goblins Implies she kills other things, or had more she should or could tell the Paladin She told the Paladin that she [only] kills goblins You covered part of this in [3], but it also implies she could be doing more to the goblins, but isn’t
minus-squareAwesome Lowlander@cozyver.selinkfedilinkEnglisharrow-up3·11 hours agoI count 7. After that the last few onlys are redundant.
minus-squareLifeInMultipleChoice@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up1·11 hours agoHmm which 2 am I missing. I count 9 slots, all of which it could go. But the meanings duplicate for me.
minus-squareAwesome Lowlander@cozyver.selinkfedilinkEnglisharrow-up2·11 hours agoYeah 9 slots, the last 3 slots are identical. The rest all have different meanings.
minus-squareLifeInMultipleChoice@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up1·11 hours ago2,3 seem the same to me She only told the paladin that she kills goblins She told only the paladin that she kills goblins
minus-squareAwesome Lowlander@cozyver.selinkfedilinkEnglisharrow-up9·11 hours ago She only told the paladin that she kills goblins She didn’t tell the paladin anything else. She told only the paladin that she kills goblins She didn’t tell anybody else about killing goblins.
minus-squareLifeInMultipleChoice@lemmy.dbzer0.comlinkfedilinkarrow-up2·11 hours agoTrue, that wording does seem to imply there could have been more information not give that she may or may not have told in the first second slot. Thanks!
Okay so how many different meanings do we get? I’m counting 5 from a quick scan.
Edit: added 5
If you put the only in different positions and then emphasise different words of the resulting sentence, you can get a lot of meanings.
Could be used to imply “except for the fact that…”
“She thought her secrets were safe, only she told the paladin that she kills goblins. The paladin was quick to tell the King soon after.”
In a different context, “they thought they were safe; only, they weren’t really”
Implies that the Paladin had some strong reaction to being told this
Implies she kills other things, or had more she should or could tell the Paladin
You covered part of this in [3], but it also implies she could be doing more to the goblins, but isn’t
I count 7. After that the last few onlys are redundant.
Hmm which 2 am I missing. I count 9 slots, all of which it could go. But the meanings duplicate for me.
Yeah 9 slots, the last 3 slots are identical. The rest all have different meanings.
2,3 seem the same to me
She only told the paladin that she kills goblins
She told only the paladin that she kills goblins
She didn’t tell the paladin anything else.
She didn’t tell anybody else about killing goblins.
True, that wording does seem to imply there could have been more information not give that she may or may not have told in the first second slot. Thanks!