So far, I don’t see the Russo-Ukrainian War with Russia as “Imperialist” and I am wanting a sober opinion and understanding of the conflict and I am sad that Ukraine itself has become a willing sacrifice for Western imperialism to weaken and contain Russia. I don’t think Russia should occupy or break up Ukraine but I can see the appeal of the Russian speaking parts of Ukraine wanting to secede and join Russia and well, I wish this war was over in 2022 or something. I dislike how Russia makes this seem as “de-nazification” and Putin himself doesn’t see Ukraine as a legitimate country with its people despite their connection to Russia. It’s honestly depressing but I feel like I kinda want to stop concerning parts of my life on it.

  • Nadie_AZ@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    13 hours ago

    I was considering joining a socialist party in 2020. They had me read a lot of literature, one book of which talked of the 20th century. It had a chapter on Ukraine and how the US had helped with the coup in 2014 to install a nazi backed regime with the goal of starting a conflict with Russia. I sort of blew it off, agreeing that of course the US would try to start a war with Russia using an eastern European proxy.

    In 2021 I was listening to The Duran and they had a show on the talks between Ukraine and Russia. And it seemed like all was going to be resolved. ‘Oh’ I thought. I hadn’t realized what was going on. I dug a little. I seem to recall a Ukrainian legislator clamoring that the US was trying to engineer a coup in late 2013 and that video made the rounds briefly.

    In January 2022 I saw the 2015 talk by John Mearsheimer on Youtube stating that the situation in Ukraine was the Wests’ fault and went into details about it. Shortly after I saw Oliver Stone’s ‘Ukraine on Fire’ which also was saying the same things.

    The western media at the time also liked to put out stories about Ukrainian corruption being the worst in Europe and that it had a far right wing political problem.

    Then Russia invaded.

    It was like 2003 all over again. Saddam Putin was the next Hitler and Russia was the Axis of Evil part 2. The coordination was breathtaking. And people took to it so readily. I was shocked. I thought maybe viewers would push back given we’d been so blatantly lied to in 2003 and that this situation was more clearly outlined in the media just a few weeks earlier.

    Anyone remember the BBC (I think was BBC) report right at the start? They talk of how this is different because they are Blonde Hair Blue Eyed people being killed, not like those darkies in Afghanistan. And no one pushed back.

    Russia stated many times that NATO going Eastward was an existential threat to them and when NATO announced in 2007 that Georgia and Ukraine could join, Russia replied in Bucharest that there was no way that would happen. They’ve stated they will demilitarize Ukraine knowing it was a NATO proxy war from the beginning. I do not think Russia thought Ukraine would back away from the peace talks in April 2022 but we all know Boris Johnson killed those.

    So.

    Russia has to fight for its life against NATO the same way Iran has to fight for its life against the US + Israel. It is the same war. It is a war against US controlling these nations rights to self determination. And these are nations that can resist and are doing so. Is Russia perfect? No way. But it demands to be acknowledged as a Great Power (as does Iran and China) and is showing it is.

  • LocalAreaMan [he/him]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    21 hours ago

    There is only one empire on this planet, and anything opposing it will be called “imperialist” by that empire, same as when Ronald Reagan called the Soviet Union an “evil empire” after watching Star Wars.

  • 10TH_OF_SEPTEMBER_CALL [any, any]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    24 hours ago

    My take:

    The illegal dissolution of the soviet union obviously meant reverting to a bunch of ethnostate in a forever war. The dialectic between ukrainian and russians have a lot of precedent, but they are used as an excuse to sell missile. I knew some guy in kiev, they were hiding. They didn’t want to pick between the kaiser and the tsar.

  • ☭ hammer_n_SICKle ☭@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    edit-2
    1 day ago

    I was hesitant to pick sides initially because of the shameful duginist delusions that were circulated by the Kremlin, as well as their display of tsarist rhetoric and paraphernalia, and the contempt they flaunted not only for the Ukrainian regime (justifiable), but for their entire identity and peoplehood.

    The more the conflict progressed however, the clearer it appeared that the Western side didn’t have any higher consideration of the Ukrainian society than the Russians, and was willing to sacrifice their lives, liberties and even demographic perspectives in order to score their petty goals against Russia.

    Whether the easter parts of Ukraine should be annexed to Russia, I don’t think will change anything fundamental in the conflict, beside making Ukraine weaker, and therefore more susceptible to foreign influences.

    The only resolution that I can see is one brought by a complete regime change in Ukraine, one that is able to pursue its own interests rather than serve as pawn for foreign powers. How likely that is, however, is anybody’s guess.

    • 10TH_OF_SEPTEMBER_CALL [any, any]@hexbear.net
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      24 hours ago

      in order to score their petty goals against Russia. compensate the tendency of the rate of profit to fall by bribing politicians so they buy missiles with public money

      I dont think they give a shit about russia or ukraine. They just want to sell weapons. Half of germany growth is weapon indutry.

  • FortifiedAttack [any]@hexbear.net
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 day ago

    The impression I’ve been getting is that the Russian government is infatuated with the idea of rapprochement with Europe after the war, which is why they never respond decisively to any NATO attacks or provocations.

    It’s funny how Europeans scream about “appeasement” whenever someone is anti-war, when Putin himself is the high appeaser supreme.

    If Russia had actually taken more decisive action earlier in the war, the bloodshed would already have ended.

    • DonLongSchlong@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      16 hours ago

      I believe this infatuation has withered away by now. I am sure they will try not to be overtly hostile, especially with China demanding stability, but it seems like their eyes have been turned towards Asia now.

  • LemmyBruceLeeMarvin@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 day ago

    it’s a war between banks. IMF/World bank loans and austerity vs. Russian central bank threatening to provide better rates. Oh, and there are critical minerals the capitalists need for war and electronics. there are no good guys in this but imho Putin fell into a trap, the US was basically begging him to invade

  • cfgaussian@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 day ago

    This is not a controversial take here. The consensus is that it is a proxy war waged by NATO imperialism against Russia using a fascist regime as its pawn. Whether or not Putin is serious about de-nazification is not knowable, but the clear reality is that Ukraine, whatever shape it ends up in, must be de-nazified, de-militarized and permanently detached from NATO, otherwise this conflict will never end.