Source: Phoronix

  • Undeclared_Mustard@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    6
    ·
    8 hours ago

    Leah commented on the article:

    Absolutely dishonest article. Completely dishonest in every conceivable way. Here is Libreboot’s actual new anti-AI policy:

    AI Slop Reduction Policy -> https://libreboot.org/news/clankers.html

    It states quite clearly that efforts will be made to reduce the amount of AI slop in upstream codebases. Unlike the now-deleted policy, it doesn’t outright ban AI, noting that such absolutism is foolish precisely because it is impossible to track everything. The article simply states: efforts will be made. It then goes on to make a few notable exceptions, under the strictest of circumstances: where the alternative is a binary blob, that someone has reverse engineered with AI, where the engineer doing the work is otherwise competent… read the article if you’re interested.

    I suspect that Michael of Phoronix like has indeed read this article, and chose to ignore it just like he ignored Libreboot 26.10 and 26.11, which were massive new releases that added full UEFI support, hundreds of Chromebooks, and beyond this completely modernised the project in every way. Several other small news sites did cover it.

    He ignored two major releases, ignored the current AI policy, and decided to write an article focusing only on the deletion of the old AI policy without covering its replacement.

    I like it when I have adversaries that come at me head-on. If he wants to criticise something, constructively and even brutally, I would welcome that. Skewing facts by omitting nearly all of them is dishonest journalism, and makes me lose what little faith I had left in the trustworthiness more generally of Phoronix.

    Shame. I will say no more. My interest in creating this account was only to ensure that the full facts are given.

  • ImgurRefugee114@reddthat.com
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    15 hours ago

    i’m never going to enforce it. recent observations of upstream code and the way things are going tells me that i’m going to make all kinds of exceptions to it over time, and not be able to fight against the tide i got too excited writing it. i believe everything in it. but it’s an unenforceable policy.

    i will not promise what i cannot / will not reliably deliver. delete unreliable promise.

    i don’t care if this gets me on a list. there is one thing i hate the most, and that’s hypocrites. i’d rather not be one. hence the deletion."

    Sounds like they made a tough call but I’m glad they’re being honest and realistic with their users and themselves.