https://lemmy.blahaj.zone/c/lgbtq_plus_christianity
this is probably gonna be controversial, but i mean this for people who actually follow christ’s teachings and not to be a cesspool of homophobia and transphobia.
Don’t the two contradict?
Something amusing: looking at the profiles of the people who are voting your comment up, it’s mostly people who have a history of very progressive comments and posts. They are voting you up because they think you are arguing that being religious is incompatible with being LGBTQ.
So, in a perfect illustration of horseshoe theory, you are getting the support from people who think that Christianity is wrong,
They are voring you up
😳
I remember seeing a clip a while ago of a prominent atheist getting annoyed at a self proclaimed “Christian” who rejected the resurrection. Essentially telling them to just become an Atheist at that point.
And the main reason that I had no objections to join the Orthodox Church (wife is Greek, she wanted a Church wedding and for that to happen I needed to convert to any Christian denomination) was because my priest said : “I am not going to baptize you just so you can marry in the Church, I want you to attend the Catechesis for at least the next six months. I want you to learn Orthodox doctrine, but the main reason I want you here is to understand our traditions and our values as Greeks. I don’t particularly expect you to become a devout Christian, but I do expect you to find harmony with your community, your wife and your extended family”.
He wasn’t trying to convince me to accept and blindly repeat key doctrine points. He wasn’t telling me what to do in a ritual “because that’s what God wants us to do”. He was telling me “these are what these rituals represent, and if you have some faith it will mean something for you”.
I found his take surprisingly effective. Going to Catechesis was not a chore, but something captivating. I probably wouldn’t have converted and just done the civil cerimony if the priest was just trying to brainwash me into repeating Dogma.
So you converted to Christianity just to have a church wedding?
No. I was also eager to piss off holier-than-thou assholes like you.
So essentially religious appropriation. Got it.
Seriously, read what I wrote again. I explicitly said that I wouldn’t have converted if it was only for the wedding.
And it’s ridiculous to even mention something like “appropriation”. I am disparaging you and your borderline-fundamentalist views on Christianity, not Christianity itself.
Likely depends on whether you ask the church or Jesus. We don’t really have any reliable information, but if he really was a hippie preacher, telling how god loves all of his creatures, and how you can’t hate on each other… He must have been pro Lgbtq+
But that’s just my take on it. Most people who call themselves Christians might disagree.
I think that is a stretch. He appointed Paul who clearly wrote against practicing homosexuality. (Romans 1:27, 1 Corinthians 6:9) He was anti divorce (Mark 10:9) and adultery as well, telling a woman caught in it to “go and sin no more” (John 8:11). Not “Live your truth” or “Love who you love”. Jesus gave us the Church. Now, would Jesus want us to bully those who practice homosexuality? By no means! We should still as Christians treat them with love. But between them and God, repentance is needed. But that’s between them and God. So the likes of Steven Anderson is wrong. (In fact, I don’t think Steven Anderson is even saved). And as well, this is a commandment for Christians. We have no business trying to enforce this on non-Christians.
Anyway, Jesus would probably be hated by the left today (and the right, but I don’t think that needs explaining). He spoke a lot about judgement and hell and condemnation. If anything, the left and right might unite to crucify Him these days.
People in the past said “My ideology is good and Jesus was good so Jesus must be on my side” such as the Nazis and the slaveowners. It’s dangerous logic.
1 Corinthians 6:9 is about young boys who were coerced into it, it’s not about individuals who desire to be with the other sex
It literally doesn’t say that.
1 Corinthians 6:9 ESV
Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality
The Lexham English Bible is a very literal translation:
1 Corinthians 6:9 LEB
Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived! Neither sexually immoral people, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor passive homosexual partners, nor dominant homosexual partners
The words being translated in question are
μαλακός mild, gentle; soft, effeminate οὔτε negative particle, related to μήτε as οὐ to μή, and not, neither, nor ἀρσενοκοίτης a sodomite
(Abbott-Smith: A Manual Greek Lexicon of the New Testament)
ἀρσενοκοίτης - literally means “male who lies with another male”. There’s nothing to imply there is anything to do with children.
It’s a compound word: “arsen” means man and “koite” or “koitas” or “koitai”—depending on a verb or a noun—means bed. It’s men who bed with other men.
it’s not about individuals who desire to be with the other sex
Even then, St Paul goes on to condemn this in Romans 1:26-27,
For this reason God gave them up to dishonorable passions. For their women exchanged natural relations for those that are contrary to nature; and the men likewise gave up natural relations with women and were consumed with passion for one another, men committing shameless acts with men and receiving in themselves the due penalty for their error.”
It is quite clear that the Bible depicts homosexuality as sinful.
The ESV and the LEB use Wescott and Hort’s Greek New Testament, they practiced Necromancy and created the Ghostly Guild.
Paul invented ἀρσενοκοίτης as it didn’t exist before him, and all the early instances of people who used it after him referred to young boys that had been coerced into it.
I’m aware the Bible depicts that as a sin. What I’m saying is that the reprobates in Romans 1 can’t be saved because God already gave them over to a reprobate mind, they’re incapable of belief in the gospel.
1 Corinthians 6:9 refers to people coerced into it, not those that desired to be with another man
~~> The ESV and the LEB use Wescott and Hort’s Greek New Testament, they practiced Necromancy and created the Ghostly Guild.
Then here is the New King James’ which uses the Textus Receptus:
Do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived. Neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor homosexuals, nor sodomites
St Paul is likely referring to the Septuagint which uses a similar term in Leviticus 20 (verify) ~~
I’m aware the Bible depicts that as a sin
I was working on a response here, but then saw this- what’s the point of this discussion then if you agree with me on this?
1 Corinthians 6:9 refers to people coerced into it, not those that desired to be with another man
Do you have any proof of this? Because the word literally means “men who bed with other men” and referring to the both passive and submissive.
I do sense some gymnastics going on here. The words are still in the Textus Receptus.
https://textus-receptus.com/wiki/1_Corinthians_6:9
You agree the Bible depicts homosexuality as sinful anyway, so the cultural argument doesn’t even work here. There’s no sense in me bringing up the verses pertaining to marriage and the symbolism of male and female and the purpose of that.
what’s the point of this discussion then if you agree with me on this?
Well, maybe because you believe if they’re repentant and they believe, that they can be saved.
They have passed the point of salvation long before they became sodomites.
Notice Paul didn’t sa:
- eρασταί: two men in love
- εραστης: an individual man in love with another man
- ἀνδροβάτης: men having sex with men or man who mounts men
- αρρενομανής & ἀρρενομιξία: men having sex with males
- κολομπαράδες: the active sexual man on top (the penetrator)
- κῐ́ναιδος: the sexual man on the bottom (the man being penetrated)
- ἑταιρίστριαι: female lovers
The New King James still relied on the Alexandrian Line of Manuscripts that Wescott and Hort relied on.
The Septuagint didn’t exist at the time of Paul. Show me an earlier Septuagint than Origen’s Hexapla.
I’ll show you the early instances that they all referred to beong coerced, rather than individuals that desired to be withn another man.
Yes, being a sodomite is a sin. People that commit that were given to a reprobate mind LONG before they committed that, they’re incapable of belief. They certainly had the chance to believe and be saved at one point but after knowing and understanding who God truly is, they chose to have nothing to do with him, so they chose not to believe. After that point those people are incapable of believing the gospel anymore
Uh, that’s mainly your opinion. I’m pretty sure both passages you gave remain contested. It’s likely about male pederasty or prostitution while sex between men in general might be completely fine. And we know for example what Paul’s role was, and that was to do politics, not quote Jesus verbatim. So you have to look at the context. That part in Romans is mainly a summary of Hellenistic Jewish legalism, not anything new, not even really about Jesus. It’s the customs of the jewish people.
Corinthans again doesn’t condemn homosexuality, but you need to read several paragraphs on ancient greek and history to even understand what the word even means. It’s not as easy as “homosexuality” to which it has been wrongfully translated.
I don’t see a strong argument why male homosexuality should be wrong. Most other passages also talk about it in the context of violence or abuse. And we can all agree that’s wrong. But a loving homosexual relationship is a different thing. And then someone still needs to quote some bible verses to me regarding lesbians, trans-people, … They’re obviously accepted and loved by the Christian community, are they?
Jesus taught us not to accept man-made bullshit like right-wing politics or hate. He’s figuratively come to earth to oppose conservatism. He taught us to use our own brains instead and try love and understanding towards other creatures. And have respect before God’s creation. Which includes a variety of sexual preference and identity. Especially being the underdog and caring for the weak people is what he did and central to leftist-liberal ideology. And opposed by the right.
And I think if your objective were to be to follow the footsteps of Jesus, you’d have dinner with the adulterers, go visit the prostitutes and embrace them, let them wash and perfume your feet. And have everyone give money to the poor. Not do anything else, especially not shit on them. Because that’s what he did.
And he wasn’t super fond of the Church either. I mean he went there and yelled at people for what they did to his father’s place. Opposed the clerics…
So how does that suddenly translate into nazis, slaveowners etc? That’s clearly wrong by his teachings. On the contrary, he came to abolish exactly these kinds of things.
Corinthians uses the word Arsenokoitai. It is also found in 1 Timothy 1:10 and in the Septuagint translation of Leviticus 18:22 and 20:13.
It is a compound word, formed from “arsen” (male) and “koitēs” (bed), so essentially meaning “men who bed with other men”. Biblical scholars who translate the Bible and know ancient greek always seem to translate it to be people who practice homosexuality or anal sexual intercourse. Basically every reputable translation of the Bible translates it along those lines, and the Church has held that interpretation universally throughout the majority of it’s history with no dispute. People are only starting to try and reinterpret it in the wake of the pride movement- which is Eisegesis, not Exegesis, and completely dishonest.
There is no evidence in the text anywhere that it could be indicating paedastry
Now, as for a loving relationship versus the violence or abuse argument, what Paul writes in Romans basically debunks that theory completely:
Romans 1:26-27 NRSV
For this reason God gave them up to degrading passions. Their women exchanged natural intercourse for unnatural, and in the same way also the men, giving up natural intercourse with women, were consumed with passion for one another. Men committed shameless acts with men and received in their own persons the due penalty for their error.
were consumed with passion for one another
Indicates a consensual relationship involving a passion. In no place here is violence indicated. In fact, quite the opposite.
Trying to claim that Jesus fits in any secular political viewpoint (leftism, conservatism) is a very shallow view and completely incorrect.
And I think if your objective were to be to follow the footsteps of Jesus, you’d have dinner with the adulterers, go visit the prostitutes and embrace them, let them wash and perfume your feet. And have everyone give money to the poor. Not do anything else, especially not shit on them. Because that’s what he did.
And I think here, you’re absolutely right. Although by “embrace” them, not to necessarily affirm what they’re doing, but to show them love in their sinful state. Christ didn’t come to save the just (which none of us are) but the unjust.
And he wasn’t super fond of the Church either. I mean he went there and yelled at people for what they did to his father’s place. Opposed the clerics…
Namely the Pharisees who were more concerned about the law than the Gospel.
So how does that suddenly translate into nazis, slaveowners etc? That’s clearly wrong by his teachings. On the contrary, he came to abolish exactly these kinds of things.
By reinterpreting the Bible in your own way, and letting your worldly passions fit your interpretation (Eisegesis) instead of letting the Bible shape you and your viewpoint (Exegesis)
One thing I learned was simple. If I have a problem with something the Bible says, if it doesn’t fit my worldview, then I’m the one with the problem and needs to be fixed. Not the Bible. As a human, I can be wrong, and need to be corrected by scripture. And I should do the best I can to follow what I am commanded to in Scripture.
Essentially, if I disagree with the Bible, then I’m the one who’s wrong. Not the Bible.
[…] Arsenokoitai
Yeah, I read some 3 page essay on how that word was used. I know “every reputable translation of the Bible translates it along those lines” but that doesn’t make it correct to translate it to a different word in and view it from a different perspective / a different context 2000 years later. I think it’s ambiguous at best. And skipping the 3 pages and making it about todays homosexuals is an oversimplicifaction and simply wrong.
[…] Eisegesis, not Exegesis
I’m not that educated on church doctrine, but do we even have access to exegesis? I mean sure technically the scripture is the meaning by definition. But isn’t what Paul writes already something like eisegesis? I mean he’s a human and he interpreted and spread the teachings for us.
no evidence in the text anywhere that it could be indicating pederasty
Well, I think pederasty is very wrong. If that part of the Bible fails to recognize or even mention that, I condemn the scripture for that.
Romans 1:26-27
Again, that’s Paul’s summary of Hellenistic legalism. That’s the entire context of that part of Romans.
Trying to claim that Jesus fits in any secular political viewpoint (leftism, conservatism) is a very shallow view and completely incorrect.
I know. The entire left/right spectrum is completely incorrect. But I gave some examples of what kind of person Jesus was and if he advocated for the people and the weak, or for the strong ones and the establishment. He happens to have quite some overlap there with core leftist ideology.
you’d have dinner with the adulterers […]
And I think here, you’re absolutely right. Although […]
There is no “although”. He clearly left out picking on their “sinful state” the way the other people did. He went there and all he had was love. It’s not super straightforward but I’m pretty sure we can skip lecturing them on those kinds of “sins”.
By reinterpreting the Bible in your own way […] Essentially, if I disagree with the Bible, then I’m the one who’s wrong. Not the Bible.
Yeah I mean good luck with that. It’s full of contradictions, stuff that was written after Jesus. You need to believe the earth is 6000 years old and rectancular with angels in the four corners playing the trumpet on doomsday. (Which should have happened a long time ago, but it didn’t.) And you can’t even tell whether it’s okay to eat Shrimp or a cheeseburger unless you do Eisegesis. Slavery and a lot of things we view as wrong today aren’t technically outlawed by the Bible and it really depends on what part of it you refer to when judging. Then we have weird parts especially in the old scripture like you can’t go to church if you’re missing a testicle or you’re asian. And I’m pretty sure all the raining frogs and so on is made up and not meant to be taken literally.
But isn’t what Paul writes already something like eisegesis? I mean he’s a human and he interpreted and spread the teachings for us.
By the appointment of Christ and the power of the Holy Spirit
I condemn the scripture for that.
You aren’t in any position to condemn the inspired word of God
There is no “although”
The “although” I placed there was because I wanted to make sure that you didn’t show Jesus as claiming that sin isn’t sin, and I was agreeing to a misunderstanding of what you were saying.
Yeah I mean good luck with that. It’s full of contradictions, stuff that was written after Jesus. You need to believe the earth is 6000 years old and rectancular
The Bible doesn’t say that.
And you can’t even tell whether it’s okay to eat Shrimp or a cheeseburger unless you do Eisegesis.
It’s not as Eisegesis, it’s covenant theology. The Council of Jerusalem in Acts 15 also highlights this, as does Paul in several of his epistles. It’s why we don’t circumcise men anymore.
Slavery and a lot of things we view as wrong today aren’t outlawed by the Bible and it really depends on what part of it you refer to when judging.
Chattel Slavery that existed in 1700-1800s America wasn’t happening in that society.
And I’m pretty sure all the raining frogs and so on is made up and not meant to be taken literally.
Are you talking about the plagues of Moses? If that’s the case, then what do you propose happened?
You are drawing a huge and dangerous brush over here. The Bible is a compilation of 66 divinely inspired books. Some are poetry and some are prophecy, like the imagery in Isaiah, Daniel, Ezekiel, Revelation, etc. It is obvious then that stuff like that is up for interpretation. But then when you get to Paul’s epistles which are separate literary works, and he says
1 Timothy 1:9-11 ESV
understanding this, that the law is not laid down for the just but for the lawless and disobedient, for the ungodly and sinners, for the unholy and profane, for those who strike their fathers and mothers, for murderers, the sexually immoral, men who practice homosexuality, enslavers, liars, perjurers, and whatever else is contrary to sound doctrine, in accordance with the gospel of the glory of the blessed God with which I have been entrusted.
It isn’t figurative that enslavers, liars, murderers are evil (at least I hope not) so why do you grant homosexuality an exception?
1 Corinthians 6:9-11 ESV
Or do you not know that the unrighteous will not inherit the kingdom of God? Do not be deceived: neither the sexually immoral, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, nor men who practice homosexuality, nor thieves, nor the greedy, nor drunkards, nor revilers, nor swindlers will inherit the kingdom of God. And such were some of you. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ and by the Spirit of our God.
This doesn’t come off as figurative either.
If the whole Bible can be taken figuratively like you argue, then we can discard Jesus’ teaching on forgiveness when someone is a former pornstar, and we can say “oh, you’re too far gone to be forgiven” “Oh, he meant everyone else, not you, sweetie”
Using God to justify hate is so last Millenium. Be more honest and say you don’t like it, God doesn’t need your help to look gross.
Only for those who take literal meaning and instruction from the Bible. Honestly, nobody who follows any holy book to the letter is fit to live in a society. They can’t change their believes and they don’t have you change themselves. More power to them really
Only for those who take literal meaning and instruction from the Bible
So… Christians
Never personally meet one that did. I’m sure there are, but the only time somebody rejected evolution on the grounds of religion was a Muslim, and a zealot.
I’m not judging all Muslims because of him, neither all Christians because the worse of them.
I think there’s a level of literalism that people talk about. The claims made about homosexuality come off as very literal as they’re letters to a congregation. The creation narrative was likely oral tradition written down after many generations, so you can attribute symbolism to it.
We are all sinners, aren’t we?
Yes
So, what is the contradiction here?
Just because we’re all sinners isn’t a licence to sin.
That does not answer the question.
Do you think a “divorced Christians” community would be a contradiction?
If they were affirming unbiblical divorces, or seeking to remarry and encouraging it, yes
You haven’t even seen what the community is about and yet you are ready to pass judgement on it.
talk about getting screwed over from both sides.
best of luck to you and your comm!
thanks so much!!






