With the US midterms around the corner, the usual mob of McCarthyists are already out in force, harassing anyone they perceive to be a) non-American or anti-American, and/or b) a revolutionary anarchist/socialist, and/or c) someone who criticisms the Democratic party and the abject failure of the two-party system to work in the interests of the people instead of in the interests of capital.
My take on this is as follows:
-
We already take mod actions based on electoralism, especially when it involves shaming others for being anti-electoralism. E.g. the classic: “If you criticize the Democrats you are helping Trump hurr durr” type of claim. So this is simply codifying the rule.
-
Based on past experience, this situation is only going to get worse as we get closer to November 3, as Democrats start accusing leftists of being foreign actors and paid shills at every turn simply because we refuse to parrot the “vote blue no matter who” line. To be clear, my view is that Americans are solely responsible for the rise of fascism in their own country, not the Russians or the Chinese (and no, that doesn’t mean I support those states either - they are also responsible for their own bullshit).
Given that context, the proposed rule is simple:
No shaming people for being anti-electoralism.
Important note: I have no problem with people voting, or promoting voting, but if it veers into shaming people for not voting, or shaming those who vote according to their conscience, then it wouldn’t be allowed.
Examples of electoralism’s tendency to troll and shame others:
- “A vote for third party is a vote for Trump.” aka “You are a Trump supporter, nah nah!” ❌
- “You are a Nazi/fascist if you don’t vote Democrat.” aka “You are a nazi/fascist Trump supporter, nah nah!” ❌
- “Its very suspicious you are being critical of [Democratic candidate] just before an election. You clearly want Trump to win.” aka “You are a secretly a Trump agent/supporter, nah nah!” ❌
- “Voting is the only way to make change in this country” aka “Work strictly within the system, or you are a terrorist, nah nah!”. ❌
- “A vote for Jill Stein is a vote for Trump.” aka “How dare you vote third party, what is this a functioning democracy?”. ❌
- “Are you even American? It’s suspicious you are talking so much about US politics.” aka “Fuck off foreigners, only Americans can have a legit opinion on US politics, you must be a foreign agent.” ❌
- Lastly, assuming someone doesn’t vote, or votes against the Democrats just because they are critical of Democrat policies and politicians is just bad-faith bullshit. Please don’t make bad-faith assumptions. Though we are critical of the Democrats I think the vast majority of our US members still hold their noses and throw them a vote, despite everything.
Examples of electoralists not being assholes:
- “Get out and vote to help make a difference in the mid-terms!” ️✅
- “Voting is super important to help reduce harms, alongside your other activism.” ️✅
- “This is an important election, every vote counts” ️✅
Further context and readings:
- https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/tanze-vatt-7-reasons-to-hate-election-season#toc6
- https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/rafael-v-da-silva-kauan-willian-and-victor-khaled-anarchism-in-the-face-of-fascism-and-the-elec#toc4
- https://theanarchistlibrary.org/library/it-s-going-down-the-election-cycle-as-counter-insurgency
This vote will end in 7 days, with simple majority voting,
As always, I encourage our other FAF admins and users to share their takes on this topic in this post. Also, should it be “No shaming people for being anti-electoralism” or “No shaming people for being anti-electoralist”? I only used the ism ending simply because I think it’s maybe better understood as a concept, but I’m not sure its grammatically correct :p
expiry: 7
Have at it, mateys.


“A vote for third party/Jill Stein is a vote for Trump.”❌ is literally a harm-reduction argument ️✅. Anti-electoralism is being against the institutional power that vesting everything on elections creates and the spectacle to maintain it that critically diverts from mutual aid, not censoring those against supporting specific candidates (and using arguments logically proven from agreeable FPTP assumptions). (In fact, I would say that level of participation is electoralist.) I do not want us to become bureaucratic “alongside your other activism” boilerplaters.
Of the examples, only #4 seems like it should be removed for anti-electoralism. Of the rest, #2, #3, and #6 should be removed, but because they are already removeable as shitty bad-jacketing.