Mastodon

Have you ever considered that the Prime Directive is not only not ethical, but also illogical, and perhaps morally indefensible?

  • 420 Posts
  • 103 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle





















  • It’s not the most forgettable episode of the revival (more on that next week), but it’s close.

    It’s not bad, really, but the plot is so threadbare that Lazarus being hauled away in the ambulance seems like a natural end point, even though there’s a fair bit of episode remaining.

    It’s a really good Martha episode, though. She gets to be a scientist, she gets to be a doctor, she gets to be an action hero, and she gets to grow a backbone and stand up to the doctor. As a resolution to the “unrequited love” angle, it’s quite effective.

    It’s a pretty bad Tish episode, though. Showing her standing up to the creepy advances of her wealthy and powerful boss, only to become willing to acquiesce to them once he’s younger was…certainly a choice that they made. Some twenty years later, it’s hard to imagine that they ever would go that route were they to make it today. It doesn’t help that Mark Gatiss does not have the magnetic charisma required for this to be remotely believable.

    The episode also kicks the Harold Saxon arc into high gear. It’s interesting that the Master has an interest in Lazarus’s work - I suppose it must have something to do with the Toclafane, but I can’t remember if that’s ever made explicit. I never noticed before that the logo of Lazarus’s company is clearly (incomplete) Gallifreyan script, which is neat. I don’t think you can call it foreshadowing, because I don’t think we’ve seen Gallifreyan script at all before now, but the wiki tells me the same logo is later seen in the Master’s ring, with the missing bits filled in.

    And of course, it must be said that this episode has some of the dodgiest CGI of the series so far. They probably would have been better off with a puppet. It’s also odd that they didn’t seem to model the creature after Mark Gatiss at all (or if they did, they missed the mark quite badly).


















  • Whatever endearing qualities existed in the first part of this story are almost completely absent in the second. It’s mostly a lot of things happening, and most of them don’t make sense.

    The most potentially interesting storyline is Dalek Sec’s newfound humanity, but it’s made abrupt and dull. The concept was played with more successfully back in “Dalek”, and will be played with again more successfully in the future.

    The Doctor offers himself as a sacrifice to save the residents of Hooverville, despite there being no real reason for the Daleks to spare them even if he does surrender - the ploy only works because Sec has a sudden change of heart, and he’s not even there for the Doctor to appeal to.

    The Daleks’ plan revolves around a solar flare, but the eventual power source for their experiment is a bolt of lightning?

    The Daleks’ betrayal of Sec is actually a high point, particularly because their doubts were clear in their “body language” even in the last episode. But then they keep Sec alive for…some reason, even though that’s an extremely un-Dalek thing to do.

    The remnant of the Cult of Skaro recalibrate the machine to convert the humans with pure Dalek DNA, so of course they come out the other end looking exactly like regular humans, without even Sec’s goofy hybrid makeup. Their laser Tommy guns are pretty fun, though.

    The idea of a Dalek-Time Lord hybrid species is glossed over so quickly it doesn’t have any time at all to land, even though the episode tries to make a big deal out of it.

    Dalek Caan escapes without killing the Doctor, because the plot says so.

    The Doctor can use the genetic machine to save Laszlo’s life, but can’t turn him back into a regular human. Okay.

    Martha’s still hung up on the Doctor. What a thrilling plot twist.

    What a shame. Despite the obvious flaws in the first part, this episode thoroughly fails to salvage the interesting bits.