monovergent 🛠️

  • 20 Posts
  • 138 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: November 27th, 2023

help-circle
rss


  • Also have been using Debian for the past 3 years. It just works on all of my machines and comes with just enough features to make life easy. Also love the variety of packages and compatibility with pretty much anything I need that isn’t in the official repo.

    Many would beg to differ but I love how stable and predictable it is. I have a very particular taste in UI and the less work to maintain that cozy look, the better. Having been a holdout on old Windows versions in the years before I moved to Linux, getting new features at all is already very exciting. I had thought for several years that nothing would beat the comfort and reliability of Windows 2000, but Debian proved me wrong.




  • Customizations, especially theming, at the system level. Or just learning to modify system files on an atomic distro, in general.

    I’m sure it’s doable and I am genuinely interested in moving to atomic/immutable distros. But more for the security aspect than reliability as I’ve yet to break my install of Linux in a way that takes more than an hour to recover from. I’ve enjoyed the predictability of Debian and my very particular taste in UI makes for additional baggage just reinstalling, let alone moving to a very different distro.




  • It’s certainly doable and something like that was my setup for a few years. There isn’t much in the way of distros or software packages that provide such a ‘personal multiseat’ configuration out of the box.

    I wanted bare metal GUI access, so instead of using Proxmox, I went about configuring Debian to the task. This might not directly answer any questions, but here's an idea of what it looked like.

    Hardware

    • i7, 48 GB RAM, 500 W PSU
    • GTX 1650 (passed through to VM), Radeon R5 340X (basic bare metal output)
    • 60 GB SSD boot disk
    • 1 TB SSD for VM images
    • 2 x 4 TB HDD for NAS
    • 1 TB HDD for testing, “overflow”, etc.

    Boot disk

    • Debian stable with XFCE
    • Virtual machines set up through virt-manager and each port forwarded to LAN
    • unattended-upgrades, ufw / iptables firewall
    • GUI more for ease of management, software on bare metal kept to a minimum

    Virtual machines / (RAM allotment)

    • Desktop (10 GB): I would use this VM while seated at the machine for productivity and web browsing.
    • NAS / media server (4 GB): both 4 TB HDDs passed through to this VM, which hosted a Samba file server and Jellyfin. Also served as file storage for a couple other VMs via internal connections. 4 TB of usable capacity since I set it to rsync to the second drive at 02:30 every morning.
    • Misc. services (4 GB): second Samba file server for devices I wanted to sync but didn’t trust with access to my full 4 TB library. Also an Apache server to host a couple of HTML pages on LAN. Various other services tested here as well.
    • Windows (8 GB)
    • GPU access (16 GB): GTX 1650 forwarded here. Intended for gaming, but ended up using it for Stable Diffusion and LLMs for reasons below.

    I’d suggest starting with anything graphically intensive running on bare metal and setting up a VM with virt-manager / Virtualbox / etc. for the NAS part. Get a couple of disks specifically to pass through to the NAS VM, forward its ports to LAN, and connect to them on the host as you would any other machine. For a desk further away, you may be able to get away with a KVM extender, but I can’t say I’ve any experience with them.

    If you try to virtualize everything like I did, there’s a couple of hurdles:

    • Much time and manual configuration in the command line is needed
    • Atrocious graphical and input latency on remote connections
    • Very high RAM usage
    • Input glitches and general slowness on the VM with GPU passthrough, remained unresolved despite scouring tutorials from people who somehow managed to get buttery-smooth gaming in a VM
    • Lots of bandwidth used while updating all of the VMs. Probably optimizable, but not out of the box.

    Go for AMD if you can, but NVIDIA hasn’t given me much trouble either. Make sure to install the driver from your distro’s repo, not NVIDIA’s website. IMO, this is less of an issue if you decide to pass through the GPU to a VM since any NVIDIA driver shenanigans will be contained to the VM.




  • Debian stable:

    • Works on all of my devices, none of which are newer than 2019
    • Compatibility with all of the software that I use day to day
    • I like my system set up in a very particular way and the stability makes upkeep simple
    • I was a holdout on older Windows versions before I moved to Linux, so getting new features at all is already exciting



  • Also got the same impression back when I used XScreenSaver from jwz. I looked in to customizing the logo shown on the login dialog and some of the screensavers, only to find a rather preachy write-up on the advantages of XScreenSaver and a very stubborn affirmation that the logo is hard-coded and should not be changed because it is the identity of the program or something.




  • In an academic setting, LibreOffice is a good substitute if:

    • Documents will not be passed back and forth between LibreOffice and MS Office for collaboration
    • Teachers accept assignments in PDF format

    I got away with using LibreOffice in university since:

    • Opening and reading files prepared in MS Office almost always works
    • Every formatting option I had used in MS Office was also present in LibreOffice
    • Professors accepted work I prepared in LibreOffice and exported as PDF to guarantee that my formatting stays intact
    • Students and professors almost always used Google Docs for collaborative work

    From experience, a moderately-formatted document with images will survive about 3 round trips between MS Office and LibreOffice before something breaks (things on the page get completely rearranged or get stuck and can’t be moved or deleted).

    And despite having used LibreOffice for several years now, I still feel like I’m having a stroke when I see the default interface. For sanity, either set the user interface (under View menu) to tabbed or sidebar, or customize the toolbar to match that of Google Docs.