

A nation that enslaves another forges its own chains.
The reason why Americans don’t do anything. The United States is the modern English empire.


A nation that enslaves another forges its own chains.
The reason why Americans don’t do anything. The United States is the modern English empire.


Bruh, it’s never the scabs who are the real problem.


Yes, and Mom & Pop are also exploiting their own children for unpaid child labor.


This is the logic of fascism. It happened in colonialist empires everywhere.
There are examples in the US, South Africa, and Rhodesia where white workers unions organized to prevent black slave labor from taking their jobs.
This is also where a lot of the anti-Chinese racism came from because Chinese immigrants were replacing higher paying white rail-worker jobs. It was a point of conflict between the American white working class and the American bourgeoisie who would rather employ Chinese worker they could pay inhumanely low wages to (although the reason why they were so exploitable was because of racism).
It’s revisionist to say that this was entirely imposed upon workers from above. White workers were given the easier choice to improve conditions somewhat for themselves without risking much by punching down on colonized workers. In every scenario where this has happened in history, the majority of the racially privileged working class have always sided with colonialism against the colonized working class (it is a statistical law) because it was the safest and easiest way to guarantee some economic security.


Then what is your position? If you’re in the global North, then what’s the point of constantly pointing out that both sides are bad when you agree that one side is worse?
It’s like the communists writing letters to Iranian prisoners coinciding with Iran getting invaded. Why now? Why is this your priority?


Well, since we exist in the real world. Tell me. What’s the most likely scenario if China splits up into however many entities you think would be enough to achieve decolonization. I already know it’s a policy of the US government to support this. So, who would benefit the most from that?


I don’t gargle China’s boot, but I think it’s a little hypocritical to equally condemn the US and China as if the two things are comparable. China isn’t in the imperial core and its workers are exploited by Western finance capital, China only passively benefits from looking the other way when they get cheap commodities imported from Africa or India, they are not the ones who actually colonize the global South and cause unequal exchange to exist, they don’t install comprador dictatorships, or engage in imperialist war. In fact, most of the time they side with the anti-imperialist side for realpolitik reasons against the US.
Comparing Western and Eastern chauvinism as if they’re the same is the Western chauvinism I am talking about, you are underplaying Western imperialism and over exaggerating Eastern imperialism to make a false equivalence. China is a tiny empire, but because they’re a tiny empire their active imperialism pretty much ends outside their borders and their interests right now are undermining the power of Western capital, making them extremely useful for the global South to develop into self-sufficiency and break out of neocolonialism. A globalized system of extraction is much worse than a fractured world of many petty empires, a worker’s revolution is much more likely to succeed in the ladder, in the former most of the capital in the world is organized against them.
You should know that imperialism is a systemic thing, not a policy of individual states, that’s not materialist at all. Imperialism is based on monopoly power and is driven by things like unequal exchange and debt trapping, and enforced by things like weaponized specialization, balkanization, and military aid for comprador governments or interventions.
Imperialism has to be fractured into semi equal parts or else the largest part (the West) will just divide and conquer the smaller parts. I support China only in so far as they’re a huge fracture in the previously world-spanning neoliberal empire of finance and oil based in the West. God willing, it fractures further.


I actually am pro-purity test, especially on the English speaking internet which is filled with Amerikkkans, Englanders, and Klanadians. Those people should only be accepted in leftist spaces after they have erased all of the vestiges of their Western supremacism.


None of these people disagreeing with me can even articulate why I might be wrong, because they know it’s true. The (white) American left is only concerned with, at best, building social democracy for American citizens. They will not talk about unequal exchange or the monopoly power of their financial system, they don’t want to think about the idea that they’re a settler colonialist project, they don’t want to think that “veterans” are really child murderers, or that they benefit from being part of the consumerist organ of global capitalism. At best they acknowledge these things in passing, wish something could be done about it, sigh, and then go right back to supporting stuff that only benefits them.
The fact that they are stuck between two fences like this is the reason they don’t do anything, and they just let things slowly get worse. The white Westerners are like frogs in a pot of water and the people of the imperial periphery, and the internal colonized populations of the core (black people, immigrants, and native people) are directly on the element beneath the pot that’s crushing down on them and they are struggling for their lives, but the white people will only think it’s kinda hot, make only languid and useless efforts to escape, then die too eventually, but be too fucking ignorant to realize what’s actually happening and as they’re getting cooked they think that maybe the people that we’re crushing struggling under us is what’s generating the heat, or maybe we can insulate the bottom of the pot, instead of trying to move the pot off the element.


Well are you what I just described? The meme is complaining about Western chauvinists, are you not opposed to that?


Wow, this many down-votes, already? You throw an insult on the floor and its recipients come to pick it up.


Nuance between imperialism and anti-imperialism. Room in your head for a little bit of American chauvinism?


How is this not true? How can anyone possibly reconcile supporting the existence of the US government as being compatible with leftism?


The labor aristocracy and the “middle class” exists as a consequence of capitalists paying a portion of workers less than is required for social reproduction (underpricing their labor-power) and then selling these commodities to a group of more well-off workers, pocketing some of the super profits for themselves, but also sacrificing some to reduce the price of their commodities below what would usually be profitable, reducing the cost of consumption for already well-off workers, entrenching them as a middle class whose function is to consume. These people can become, on occasion, so wealthy (for a worker) that they can invest their money and turn it into capital, becoming petite bourgeois. This is the mechanism of increasing wage disparity. It doesn’t even need a conspiracy.
Yes, but the examples in recent history are often instigated. Like salafists wouldn’t have anywhere near the same influence without Saudi Arabia, and Saudi Arabia basically wouldn’t exist without US support.
The Shi’a Sunni sectarianism was helped (at least in Syria) by the US government.
https://wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/06DAMASCUS5399_a.html

Well, that’s ineffectual if it prevents you from having solidarity with the Axis of Resistance, the Alliance of Sahel States, the DRC in the conflict with Rwanda, Russia in ending the war against the Western-backed Ukrainian government, and the Sudanese Armed Forces against the UAE-backed RSF. We should put our support behind all anti-imperialist groups.


Bullying works.
The first one sometimes has a physical paywall, though.