Written by: Stephen Greenhorn

Directed by: Richard Clark

  • SpaceScotsman@startrek.website
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 day ago

    The episode isn’t quite as bad as I remember, there’s definitely some good stuff in here,even if the episode overall is imperfect.

    There’s something about this story that feels like quite retro - those old scientists and their abominations against nature. But I feel the whole question of ageing is underplayed against the monster attack. It’s not until the confrontation at the very end that we get a meaningful discussion about how human it is to want to cling to life. There is a nice bit of direction at the very end - We see the dead body as old, through the doctor eyes, rather than the young body he’s actually in post-transformation. It’s ambiguous in a good way. There isn’t enough input from The Doctor throughout the episode for what it means to be old, considering the doctor is effectively immortal. The episode would have been better as a kind of philosophical one rather than a giant monster chase.

    The whole “boss creeping on Tish” thing is very much a topic in the news right now in the UK, but Tish plays it as far too eager the moment Lazarus becomes younger. The cold open with pining Martha is obvious. I’m not especially clued into this stuff and I noticed it. Is the doctor intentionally ignoring it? It’s pretty annoying in this episode. Though Martha does get to take charge a bit here and show some bravery, which makes her feel a little less two-dimensional.

    The effects are all over the place with this episode. The old age makeup isn’t terrible, but the CGI monster is bad. Its face looks like a flat animated texture like on something from an early tomb raider game. I do like Mark Gatiss, but he wasn’t used to best effect here given so much of the time was spent with a CGI monster. Some of the acting, like his seizure collapse wasn’t great.

    Other stuff:

    • Reversing the Polarity mentioned!
    • Another mother slap. This one has been egged on by the mysterious Saxon.
    • As well as for its organ, Southwark Cathedral (according to wikipdia) is known for being an LGBT positive congegation, an obvious choice for RTD-era DW
  • ValueSubtracted@startrek.websiteOPM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    2 days ago

    It’s not the most forgettable episode of the revival (more on that next week), but it’s close.

    It’s not bad, really, but the plot is so threadbare that Lazarus being hauled away in the ambulance seems like a natural end point, even though there’s a fair bit of episode remaining.

    It’s a really good Martha episode, though. She gets to be a scientist, she gets to be a doctor, she gets to be an action hero, and she gets to grow a backbone and stand up to the doctor. As a resolution to the “unrequited love” angle, it’s quite effective.

    It’s a pretty bad Tish episode, though. Showing her standing up to the creepy advances of her wealthy and powerful boss, only to become willing to acquiesce to them once he’s younger was…certainly a choice that they made. Some twenty years later, it’s hard to imagine that they ever would go that route were they to make it today. It doesn’t help that Mark Gatiss does not have the magnetic charisma required for this to be remotely believable.

    The episode also kicks the Harold Saxon arc into high gear. It’s interesting that the Master has an interest in Lazarus’s work - I suppose it must have something to do with the Toclafane, but I can’t remember if that’s ever made explicit. I never noticed before that the logo of Lazarus’s company is clearly (incomplete) Gallifreyan script, which is neat. I don’t think you can call it foreshadowing, because I don’t think we’ve seen Gallifreyan script at all before now, but the wiki tells me the same logo is later seen in the Master’s ring, with the missing bits filled in.

    And of course, it must be said that this episode has some of the dodgiest CGI of the series so far. They probably would have been better off with a puppet. It’s also odd that they didn’t seem to model the creature after Mark Gatiss at all (or if they did, they missed the mark quite badly).

    • SpaceScotsman@startrek.website
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 day ago

      I forgot about the mid-episode ending point. I’m not sure if that was meant to be a fake-out, or if they did sort of run out of story half way through.

    • SiliconAvatar@startrek.website
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      2 days ago

      Yeah, this pretty much exists on the strength of the leads’ chemistry. As stories go it’s entire inconsequential, and could be summed up as “the Doctor meets Martha’s family; weird stuff happens around them”.

      That CGI scorpion is pretty atrocious. Also, I forget if it’s ever explained how Lazarus has dormant scorpion genes that he could be (d)evolved into/out of/from. The whole thing is fairly nonsensical, even for a Doctor Who episode.

      If one were to compare RTD’s first and second eras, this story could be juxtaposed to “Lucky day” as a fairly humdrum monster used as backdrop for character buildup to seed a finale. Only that’s sort of generous to “Lazarus experiment” while selling “Lucky Day” short.

      Either way, this isn’t an episode I rewatch unless it’s for a full Martha-thon…

      • ValueSubtracted@startrek.websiteOPM
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        2 days ago

        Also, I forget if it’s ever explained how Lazarus has dormant scorpion genes that he could be (d)evolved into/out of/from. The whole thing is fairly nonsensical, even for a Doctor Who episode.

        There’s a handwave about the dormant genes representing an evolutionary path not taken, which…yeah, it’s nonsense, but maybe I’m just grading it on a Star Trek curve, because I actually don’t mind it!

        • SiliconAvatar@startrek.website
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          edit-2
          2 days ago

          I mean, in Star Trek TNG s07, Barclay “devolved” into a spider or something, too, so I guess there’s precedence?

          Edit: “Genesis”, blanked on the name of the episode…

          • ValueSubtracted@startrek.websiteOPM
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            0
            ·
            2 days ago

            Yeah, “Genesis” is exactly what I had in mind. I think this episode’s “road not taken” idea to be marginally less silly than TNG’s “the DNA has recombined to an earlier lifeform” one, so that extremely low bar has been cleared!