


I know that S4A has some overly-dogmatic takes (especially regarding modern AES), but what do you think about this in particular?
Copy-pasted if you have trouble with the images
Stop using “treats” (derogatory) to refer to things working people need & that make our lives better. It’s an exceptionally poor, non-Marxist framing. (And if you don’t care about that, why are you here?)
High living standards have to be won by the workers’ movement under capitalism as we attempt to push past it, into socialism. That’s elementary.
“Workers in the imperialist countries want good things haha.”
No 💩 buddy! That’s true for any country, whether imperialist or imperialized.
There’s no ethical consumption under capitalism, but we have to consume to live. We want long, happy, fulfilling lives, and we need material things for that.
In the imperialist countries, many consumer goods are obtained from imperialized countries, where capitalists seek cheaper labor, materials & overhead.
Imperialist-country workers may never visit many of the countries where the goods we use are produced, but we’re connected to them through this.
So, Marxists must connect the struggle for socialism in the imperialist countries with the struggle for self-determination (& socialism) in the imperialized countries for a united international movement against capitalism.
We must raise living standards WHILE fighting local and global exploitation.
It’s true that some social-democrats and other non-Marxist “socialists” often don’t hold a proletarian internationalist point of view, not caring where the products they consume come from, how they’re made, or who makes them.
Marxists can combat this with education on how global capitalism works.
When a revolutionary situation finally emerges, and capitalists wage full-on counterrevolution against workers, there are sure to be significant hardships as capitalists strategically attempt to withhold resources of all kinds in order to win the fight.
No worker who fears this will be able to add much to a socialist victory as they’ll be unreliable, quick to seek those out those “old” comforts at any cost to the movement, including abandoning the fight entirely and groveling to their capitalist masters for a return to exploitation.
But communists know that the only real solution for continuing to improve workers’ conditions beyond the limits of capitalism lies in crushing that system completely, whatever the relatively short term requires of us.
“Treat” discourse is wrecker shit. Nothing good ever comes of it because “treats” are not a defined concept. It is always used to create divisions between the workers inside the imperial core vs the workers outside.
Reformism has been debated and the Communist line is explicit. Movements fighting for reforms that make workers lives better under capitalism can be used for agitation. We can assist people fighting for reforms but only as long as they are open to our agitation.

treats are fine as long as they’re not egregiously exploitative of workers directly. i do not care for S4A’s views most of the time
I don’t say this in defense of S4A in particular, whose views as a whole I have little familiarity with: In concept, I do think “here’s how imperialism functions” often gets confused with “dunk on these people” in online spaces, among people who are newer to moving left. Put another way, analysis of imperialism, things such as “imperial core countries benefit from exploiting the countries they do imperialism to” gets used as a means of driving a wedge between people instead of used as a means of working through contradictions. Terms like “treatlerite” put the focus on “bad individuals” and, along with the aforementioned analysis of imperialism, tend to paint a picture of a callous class in the imperial core who is doomed to be horrible and selfish until the rest of the world produces a proletarian revolution. Organizations in the imperial core that work to have solidarity with victims of imperialism and strengthen the international proletariat are often left out of the conversation entirely; which is important because they are a great vehicle for people in the imperial core proving through action that they can materially oppose imperialism.
Remember that marxist analysis is for changing the world, not just for observing the current conditions as they are. No matter what capitalist country one lives in, they may not see a prole revolution in their lifetime. Not because the conditions for it are terrible in every capitalist country in the world, but because it’s not a mechanical process that automatically occurs when a threshold of decay reaches its zenith. A vanguard has to be built and it has to succeed against repression.
In terms of relative suffering, I could compare by individual life and say, yeah, my life is probably less bad than that of the average person in an imperialized country, or that I have more material comforts. But not only does this not mean my life is good, that all my needs are consistently met, it doesn’t mean I possess meaningful power. In the US, for example, I am made to think my vote empowers me, but in practice, it means very little; studies show that what happens as policy and what the public wants have little to do with one another.
Now if somebody wants to be mad at a rabid imperialist who acts like local healthcare is revolution, that’s one thing. But if somebody is trying to be anti-imperialist, trying to figure out how to have solidarity, and instead of recommending a solidarity org or something, the rhetoric is still about shitting on them for where they happened to be born or insisting their efforts for better are doomed to failure, that I don’t like.
I despise this kind of rhetoric so much, and whichever sides one chooses too idc. What does “treats” even mean? There’s a world of difference between providing social assistance for the disabled and producing/buying grand theft auto 6. And yet both are subsumed under the category of “treats.” Absurd.
Even with the second category, I think there is still often misunderstanding of it as cotton candy atop a fulfilling life. Like we could ask, why do people jump for a thing like gta 6 in the first place, to the point they are obsessing over news of it like it’s the second coming? I would argue under capitalism, products have reached a point of being shallow substitute for community. That what people really crave most is the sense of belonging they’d normally get from an interdependent community and because they don’t have that, they try to get it through shared interest in a product. But this is ultimately hollow and unfulfilling, so people quickly grow tired of whatever the newest product is and move onto another one. Or, in part from the social conditioning brought on by the proliferation of “live service”, they learn to live in a state of anticipation for what the next update is, instead of being able to enjoy what they have.
So I’m not sure treat is even a good word for the second category. In a zoomed out view, isn’t it just “bread and circuses”? In that sense, nothing particularly new and nothing unique to any particular country as a concept of ruling via an exploitative model. The gta type part being circus, distraction, entertainment, a way of getting the proles to kill time doing stuff that isn’t talk of revolt and make them feel invested in the stability of the system and “what will it produce next”.
I never claim to know much on a lot of stuff. I am an expert in my field, but dumb as fuck in many other fields.
That said, I feel like a lot of these conversations are over the top and missing the point.
-
People in the imperial core, objectively, make concessions with the bourgeoisie in order to get treats (read, benefits to make their lives easier). This is understandable and obvious. Of course people would do that, many people do not have class consciousness and so they will think only about what benefits themselves and their immediate neighbours.
-
Those treats are given as a direct result of oppressing the working class, usually in the global south. Therefore, those in the imperial core should be educated and deny these treats so as to target the enemy.
-
People will oppose voting full stop, and call any participation with elections as just asking for treats, entryism, etc etc.
-
It is well established by Marx, Engels, Lenin, etc, that there is A place for engaging in bourgeois elections and using it as a school for revolution. Granted, the imperial core is fucking dogshit at actually DOING that, but still the theory is there.
-
The entire conversation is starting from the wrong place. The imperial core, specifically the US, has an example of actually gaining those “treats” through Marxist-Leninist action: the Black Panther Party. It’s not the material gains that are the problem, it’s how those gains are made that we criticise.
Anyway, not sure if that made sense. Just needed to complain, as someone from the imperial core that is so fucking exhausted with American “leftists” caring more about image than action based in theory.
Ugh, I didn’t expand on my second point.
2a. People in the imperial core are not being educated or agitated. They are kept pliable through treats and comfort. There are people living in poverty in the imperial core that still think they can become a millionaire and will spit on someone from Africa if they were told to by the bourgeoisie.
2b. Education needs to be active and progressive. We need to not just tell them how things are, but how things change and what to do. Defeatism is a common excuse in the imperial core. People will go “Damn, I hate it, but I can’t do anything about it.”
-
i mean, i think there’s some truth to the fact that it is perfectly rational to act on one’s material interests, and from the perspective of everyone who does (i.e. everyone) they are doing what they should. it’s incorrect to vilify or hate exploiters of any class struggle, because they are acting just as rationally as you would be were you in the same situation as them. it’s especially disheartening to see people vilify or hate themselves as a consequence, which is in fact counterproductive towards making lasting radical change.
i also think education is important to reframe the understanding of how people in the core understand the improvement of their material conditions. but the what (contradiction between short/long term interests), how (development of an actual vanguard party), and when (as material conditions get worse in the core for myriad of reasons) here are sorely underdeveloped and likely incorrect. the latter is probably the most important, because just about any act to significantly or fundamentally improve material conditions for those who benefit from imperialism in the core is likely to be reactionary.
finally, it seems sorely underdeveloped as it relates to who does and does not get “treats” in the core. the proletarianized core is treated like a monolith, rather than having its own internal class contradictions, of which again imperialism and colonialism is the primary contradiction. this is obviously relevant not just from a theoretical standpoint but directly affects strategy and tactics as the decline of western imperialism continues.
in sum, there is some fundamental truth to it, but it is still ultimately more incorrect than it is correct.
As I’ve seen it used, “treats” doesn’t refer to “things working people need & that make our lives better” at all. It explicitly refers to the excessive and unnecessary consumption engaged in by those of the imperial core that in part has the role of keeping them pacified and complicit with imperialism. Improving conditions for workers in the imperial core by and large doesn’t mean increasing treats, it means reducing precarity.
In the imperialist countries, many consumer goods are obtained from imperialized countries, where capitalists seek cheaper labor, materials & overhead. Imperialist-country workers may never visit many of the countries where the goods we use are produced, but we’re connected to them through this.
As a slumlord I may never visit many of my leaking, mouldy, cockroach-infested properties, but the wretches enduring this squalor generate my profits and I’m connected to them through this.
It entirely depends on what qualifies as a “treat” but this guy seems biased on the Western side.
It’s a bit like the issue around animal consumption. If you think factory farming of meat is horrific, which I personally think it is, you kind of have a duty to stop or at least consciously reduce your meat consumption. Otherwise your beliefs are detached from reality if you cannot envision or follow a lifestyle not backed by industrial slaughter of animals. If you see this is as something that should be eliminated, which I am aware most meat eaters don’t, and if you talk about education and the imminence of lab grown meat, you just sound like a hypocrite.
I don’t know what counts as treats here so I can’t put it in concrete terms. But if you become mini-Hitler over something like videogames for example that is certainly a you problem lol
honestly, S4A’s solution is dumb
I can see why he was a Trot and now a… Maoist? Or Hoxhaist?
I forget which now
I think he is against China, but that hardly narrows it down.
yheah
(Note: I’m not from the Imperial Core)
As far as I understand it, “treats” mean concessions given to the working class by the bourgeoisie that are given through imperialist plunder. Some examples of treats include cheap gasoline, cheap healthcare (except in the US) etc.
I think the main problem I have with this thread is the “we” and “workers”. Who’s “we”? Who composes the workers?
The people who probably have the most revolutionary potential in the US are Black Amerikans, Latino Americans, and Indigenous people. I don’t think those people see these “treats” as often as White Amerikans.
S4A’s proposal feels a bit idealistic with “Marxists can combat this with education”. Yeah, I know that my food was probably made by someone in almost slavery in some field in Central Brazil, but what can I do to change that? Education about the origin of my products isn’t gonna help me fight for other workers.
less sure about this one:
Also, in “there are sure to be significant hardships as capitalists strategically attempt to withhold resources of all kinds in order to win the fight”, which resources is S4A referring to? Is the US bourgeoisie willingly gonna stop selling food or medicine? At the cost of their profits?
“education”
there’s your problem
education without acts or victories is meaningless
you can’t “educate” someone into activism or organizing, unless you mean to mentor someone personally in doing so, not through being an influencer on social media lol
Yep
dumb af take. we’re not against working people improving their living conditions. we’re against not seeing the forest for the tree. and there’s a real difference between periphery and core. how are we in the global south suppossed to feel about gringos whinning about hillary for some medibullshit when we’re being fucked up and down left and right front and back by the blue nazis. if your reason to support moderate fascism is a milder improvement of material reality you’re being a piece of shit. the real issue is that it seems people think you don’t have to suffer to improve reality. but the opposite is true, improving reality requires immesurable amounts of pain, suffering and blood. and since these people don’t know what it is to suffer for someone else, to suffer for someone they love, or care, or they are empathetic towards, they just are alien to the concept of a sacrifice.
if you get a treat, is because you made a concession, there’s no way around it, vampires won’t give you a penny for free, they will always ask for something in exchange. this is true at least if we’re talking about the ballot.
how are we in the global south suppossed to feel about gringos whinning about hillary for some medibullshit when we’re being fucked up and down left and right front and back by the blue nazis.
Your task is much the same as marxist-leninists in the imperial core; getting through to the liberal types in your own country who believe in reforming capitalism and going no further. If you live in an imperialized country, you may even be able to rally people around national sovereignty and cultural preservation, along with marxism, making it easier to organize them around a shared cause that they care about. Comparatively, Yankee MLs can’t rally around national pride or culture without being reactionary settlers. The indigenous of Turtle Island can rally around sovereignty and culture for their particular indigenous nation, but that’s a small portion of the makeup of the region by this point.
Point being, the task set before you is not much different. Yankee MLs don’t like hillary clinton either; you just aren’t likely to hear from them much outside of a niche forum like this because they are a minority in the region. The form of the oppressor is not identical, but there is a lot of crossover. Both imperial core MLs and imperialized nation MLs are dealing with bourgeois superstructure influence and trying to overcome it to educate and organize.
lol You gringos call us gringos even when we get thrown into prison for life or shipped to Uganda or, idk, Borneo at random.
idk if you’re white or BIPOC or the West or in the Global South, but we have literally tried sufferance as a way to spur change and it just makes people into treatlerites lol
The problem with inflecting pain on any animal so they can do something is that they need to know how to do it first, otherwiser, they’ll seek comfort at the first possible moment.
lol
i’m not saying you should torture yourself or treat pain as some christian culmination for the epitome of class struggle. i’m not treating suffering as a holy thing, but you end up suffering in the revolutionary process. stalin lost a son to the nazis. mao lost a son to the usonians. camilo cienfuegos gave his life for cuban revolution. el che died fighting for the bolivian people. allende died arms in hand while being couped. i can continue. do you think any of them would have doubted for a second about giving their life for their people? revolution requires struggle, struggle involves pain.
Sickness makes health pleasant and good; evil, good; hunger, satiety; weariness, rest.
— Heraclitus, B111 (DK 22)
History shows that wars are divided into two kinds, just and unjust. All wars that are progressive are just, and all wars that impede progress are unjust. We Communists oppose all unjust wars that impede progress, but we do not oppose progressive, just wars. Not only do we Communists not oppose just wars; we actively participate in them.
— Mao Zedong, “On Protracted War”
“camilo cienfuegos gave his life for cuban revolution. el che died fighting for the bolivian people. allende died arms in hand while being couped.”
none of this literally did anything
pain and sufferance don’t give you shit in the end
They aren’t saying their suffering was pre planned or a strategy, it just is.
yeah so
I don’t wanna assume what Soviet snake is saying here so I’m giving my own argument(Although I believe is the point they were trying to make)
The point isn’t just to suffer to cause change. The point is that class struggle will cause pain and suffering. Striking workers have to accept they might start, be hurt, die, and ultimately lose their struggle. But they have to believe victory is possible and still fight. The point isn’t to suffer, but that suffering will be inflicted on you as punishment for resisting. The point is to not fear it, but acknowledge this. Otherwise you’ll never be able to fight for revolution.
When you fight for better conditions without advancing the workers movement this is called “opportunism”. Only a workers movement grounded in advancing revolutionary goals can avoid this.
It’s like a weapons manufacturer workers fighting to establish equal pay for women or DEI hiring. This doesn’t necessarily advance the cause of the working class. But it gives treats to the opportunists among them. It does not help advance the struggle to have this token representation. But to dismantle the system, or unionize with an anti war international union in solidarity with international workers, THIS will harm the US’s ability to commit imperialism. Which is why they will resist it with as much force as they are capable of. Thus, the suffering previously mentioned.
I saw his point and if I’m interpreting it correctly, I think you’ve framed it well. And I see sister Makan’s point because I’m a part of that class she describes, in a remote, isolated area who had to drop a good portion of savings last week for an unplanned expense. I am ready to relocate and searching for a way, and it will hurt my heart to leave so many poor and oppressed behind, because I have deep love for many of them. So suffering is real, on many levels, but relocation is necessary to effect any hope of anything. So if anyone has any ideas, please help me see a way, because I have access to a car, but I am not the owner, and an elderly pet I’ve been trying to rehome so that my baby doesn’t become fight dog bait.
no matter the circumstances or ability or education one finds themselves in, they can help build towards revolution. Most revolutions in the world were dominated by the poor peasant class.
The state wants you to believe there is no alternative so that you never even try to fight. It’s optimism for revolution that they want to kill, without it you will never be free.
I understand your situation completely, and I highly recommend leaning on others for support even if it makes you feel bad. socialism is all about depending on one another, not doing the whole thing alone. If you are unable, there are state and local programs that you should take advantage of as much as possible, they are dependent on the region you are in however.
The poor and oppressed you live with are the exact people to organize and fight with, they understand the struggle most out of anyone.
You can do this comrade.
They are old, dying and have no interest. There is nothing more my state will offer, im on workers’ comp. Edit: but still searching and not giving up.
The point isn’t just to suffer to cause change. The point is that class struggle will cause pain and suffering. Striking workers have to accept they might start, be hurt, die, and ultimately lose their struggle. But they have to believe victory is possible and still fight. The point isn’t to suffer, but that suffering will be inflicted on you as punishment for resisting. The point is to not fear it, but acknowledge this. Otherwise you’ll never be able to fight for revolution.
The problem is that people literally already accept that.
You keep trying to dangle the “sufferanc” and “pain” and preparing them for more of the same that they will have to endure later, you are literally going to make your, erm, “education” backfire.
Like, backfire basically into causing the workers you’re supposedly trying to help into inaction.
smdh
glad to know your take is that the cuban revolution did anything and that el che died for nothing. you should wash your mouth before speaking in this way about revolutionary heroes.
quickly typed an edit with more elaboration; gotta run some errands.
No
Che going to Bolivia and dying there in itself did nothing
It was a loss
a waste
The Cuban revolution was not
what matters is not the “blood, sweat, and tears” that went into the project
it’s the result
i don’t give a shit about sufferance
I give a shit about success
Edit with more elaboration:
Was the movement a success or failure? If so, how did it succeed or what led to its failure?
Did the uprising succeed and result in a revolution or was it made too late or too early or without much coordination? If so, how?
Don’t give me more spiel about Jesus Chrsit.
Westernes love “sufferance.”
That’s why they put Jesus Christ on the Cross everywhere in the West because, in the West, your value is determined by how much you suffer.
Sufferance is now merit, now a treasured value.
Like, wow…
Great moral lesson right there lol /s
Now communists berate people about how the very people they should be helping are “treatlers”
I don’t agree with S4A in many things, in fact, I disagreed with him in one post submited here as well (he is also literally ableist and hurt a friend of mine and tried to drag her through the mud).
But yeesh, i can see why some leftists are seen as people looking from afar on their high horse.
Some of y’all need to get off yours already.
This is describing a tendency. Nobody is telling the workers to suffer. You’re extrapolating farther than the argument is. Reaching a conclusion nobody has stated, and thus arguing with something that is, at this point, irrelevant. Nobody is dangling these phrases in front of the workers demanding them to suffer for sufferings sake. There is nothing noble about suffering and poverty.
The point isn’t to suffer, but that suffering will be inflicted on you as punishment for resisting.
This part is directing who will inflict the suffering. It is not the strikers, it is not the organizers or the Marxists or agitators. It is the capitalists weaponizing the state.
Malcolm X described a phenomenon on the tendency “The difference between the ‘house Negro’ and the ‘field Negro.’” Although all suffer in this situation, the “house negro” example is opportunistic and would rather have his compromise than suffer revolution in solidarity.
how are we in the global south suppossed to feel about gringos whinning about hillary for some medibullshit when we’re being fucked up and down left and right front and back by the blue nazis. if your reason to support moderate fascism is a milder improvement of material reality you’re being a piece of shit. the real issue is that it seems people think you don’t have to suffer to improve reality. but the opposite is true, improving reality requires immesurable amounts of pain, suffering and blood. With this description, the frustration is that people would prefer better conditions for themselves if it means supporting the oppression of the third world. Nobody is more entitled to better living conditions than the other. It’s meant to agitate people into stopping their opportunistic behavior (Supporting oppression of the international workers, for the sake of their own comforts), and start agitating in a movement that does BOTH improve worker conditions AND halts imperialism on international workers.
I understand your frustration. Nobody is telling other people to suffer. But Soviet Snake, who was also frustrating their grievances, is pointing to a opportunistic tendency among imperial core workers. The solution of course, is agitation, organization and revolution. NOT compromise. The goal is not to lose, but it is also not to sacrifice each other.
This is describing a tendency. Nobody is telling the workers to suffer. You’re extrapolating farther than the argument is. Reaching a conclusion nobody has stated, and thus arguing with something that is, at this point, irrelevant. Nobody is dangling these phrases in front of the workers demanding them to suffer for sufferings sake. There is nothing noble about suffering and poverty.
then don’t make it one
Malcolm X described a phenomenon on the tendency “The difference between the ‘house Negro’ and the ‘field Negro.’” Although all suffer in this situation, the “house negro” example is opportunistic and would rather have his compromise than suffer revolution in solidarity.
Malcolm X wasn’t a social scientist and most people aren’t house slaves.
how are we in the global south suppossed to feel about gringos whinning about hillary for some medibullshit when we’re being fucked up and down left and right front and back by the blue nazis. if your reason to support moderate fascism is a milder improvement of material reality you’re being a piece of shit. the real issue is that it seems people think you don’t have to suffer to improve reality. but the opposite is true, improving reality requires immesurable amounts of pain, suffering and blood. With this description, the frustration is that people would prefer better conditions for themselves if it means supporting the oppression of the third world. Nobody is more entitled to better living conditions than the other. It’s meant to agitate people into stopping their opportunistic behavior (Supporting oppression of the international workers, for the sake of their own comforts), and start agitating in a movement that does BOTH improve worker conditions AND halts imperialism on international workers.
Most of Americans are poor, literally half of them since 2011.
Literally most central and eastern Europeans could be said to have a better standard of living on average.
Most of the former “second world” could
ridiculous
I felt that his analysis was way off, mainly in the differences between global south and the imperial core, but you put into words what I couldn’t articulate myself. Thanks!
knowing S4A, he probably doesn’t give a shit about that all that much, ngl, but idk how his videos, rhetoric, and content have changed since then












