I know that S4A has some overly-dogmatic takes (especially regarding modern AES), but what do you think about this in particular?

Copy-pasted if you have trouble with the images

Stop using “treats” (derogatory) to refer to things working people need & that make our lives better. It’s an exceptionally poor, non-Marxist framing. (And if you don’t care about that, why are you here?)

High living standards have to be won by the workers’ movement under capitalism as we attempt to push past it, into socialism. That’s elementary.

“Workers in the imperialist countries want good things haha.”

No 💩 buddy! That’s true for any country, whether imperialist or imperialized.

There’s no ethical consumption under capitalism, but we have to consume to live. We want long, happy, fulfilling lives, and we need material things for that.

In the imperialist countries, many consumer goods are obtained from imperialized countries, where capitalists seek cheaper labor, materials & overhead.

Imperialist-country workers may never visit many of the countries where the goods we use are produced, but we’re connected to them through this.

So, Marxists must connect the struggle for socialism in the imperialist countries with the struggle for self-determination (& socialism) in the imperialized countries for a united international movement against capitalism.

We must raise living standards WHILE fighting local and global exploitation.

It’s true that some social-democrats and other non-Marxist “socialists” often don’t hold a proletarian internationalist point of view, not caring where the products they consume come from, how they’re made, or who makes them.

Marxists can combat this with education on how global capitalism works.

When a revolutionary situation finally emerges, and capitalists wage full-on counterrevolution against workers, there are sure to be significant hardships as capitalists strategically attempt to withhold resources of all kinds in order to win the fight.

No worker who fears this will be able to add much to a socialist victory as they’ll be unreliable, quick to seek those out those “old” comforts at any cost to the movement, including abandoning the fight entirely and groveling to their capitalist masters for a return to exploitation.

But communists know that the only real solution for continuing to improve workers’ conditions beyond the limits of capitalism lies in crushing that system completely, whatever the relatively short term requires of us.

  • Maeve@kbin.earth
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    2 days ago

    They are old, dying and have no interest. There is nothing more my state will offer, im on workers’ comp. Edit: but still searching and not giving up.

    • RedLink@lemmygrad.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      2 days ago

      I’ve agitated a few elderly to help with organizing. There’s restrictions in what they can do of course, but it doesn’t stop them. If not them then others. There’s just too many people and contradictions for it to be truly impossible. Capitalists create the conditions for their own demise.

      I’m sorry that your area doesn’t have more benefits. I struggle myself as I can’t qualify for benefits despite working due to my career. I’ve been able to get aid from my closest friends and even stay in their houses when needed. Community is such an important thing to build.

      • Maeve@kbin.earth
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        2 days ago

        We had a mutual aid thing going buy people moved, got deathbed sick, went to prison. And I mean barely clinging to life in a deep red, deep south state. I am in the position of thinking providing what aid and comfort I can offer: errands, a chore, helping understand and navigate medical appointment, EOB, etc is the best use of my time. It’s challenging, rewarding, and frustrating, at once. The younger who stayed make their money in other ways…

        • RedLink@lemmygrad.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          2 days ago

          It’s what you can do, and it already helps change lives. Please stay optimistic comrade. I also organize in similar conditions. We do have the ability to make change and work towards a better tomorrow.