Written by: Chris Chibnall

Directed by: Graeme Harper

  • SpaceScotsman@startrek.website
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    3 hours ago

    There’s a quote in this episode - “Why is this happening‽”, which sums up my feelings well. I didn’t realise Chibnall had written this one - it isn’t surprising, as I wasn’t a big fan of his time as showrunner. This kind of story need halloween style slasher horror direction, but it never felt either scary or tense. I’m not sure if the title 42 is a reference to 24 or Hitchhiker’s, but it doesn’t really earn either as a reference.

    Some parts of it are good. When Martha is stuck in the escape pod, in total silence, it gives a very powerful contrast to the high speed loudness of the rest of the episode. The subsequent difficult chat with mum worked, and that whole B-story does a good job of continuing to set up Saxon as a formidable big bad. And we get our first glimpse at 10 being genuinely scared of dying, even though he can regenerate. The acting in all these moments is great.

    I have a lot of problems with the mediocre and bad stuff. Many themes felt quite recycled. The mysterious star, breaking down ship from Impossible Planet, the overheating sun from The End of the World, profit motive which runs throughout a lot of DW. Contrast this with “Midnight”, which re-uses the possession plot point from this episode in a much better way. Other plot points are just stupid - the crew of this interstellar cargo ship are stupid enough to use a door unlock system based on random trivia. It feels like the kind of high concept irreverence that would be more at place in Rick and Morty. There’s plenty of holes as well - Captain has her hand in the absolute zero stasis chamber holding someone down, then pulls it out unharmed moments later. Doctor getting infected by looking at the star, which Martha does earlier while being totally unharmed. While I’m glad there wasn’t any overt “Martha loves the Doctor” here, the crew guy creeping on Martha after they just met is weird. While I get they had an adrenaline filled moment, Martha jumping on every random men she meets is not good writing.

    The final resolution doesn’t make much sense. If I’ve understood properly, the alien is possessing people going around murdering everyone because it’s vengeful for the scoops having hurt the star. But once the scoops are emptied, it just gives up? If it wasn’t actually seeking revenge, then why didn’t it use the possessed guy to dump the scoops out. We also find out that the crew knew scoops were illegal, which means they must understand why, which begs the question why this whole episode even happened.

  • ValueSubtracted@startrek.websiteOPM
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    3 hours ago

    I suppose the fact that I find this to be the single most forgettable episode of modern Who means every time is like the first time, which is certainly something. This is another one that isn’t exactly bad - it just exists.

    I don’t think the “real time” gimmick works for a single episode of TV - it’s really not noticeable, let alone impactful. For it to be memorable, they’d probably have to do it in one continuous shot, “Adolescence” style, and I’m not sure that’s feasible in sc-fi today, let alone 20ish years ago.

    This episode also seems to try (and fail) to emulate “The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit”. This is a little unfair, since it has half the runtime, but the end result is that it feels like it’s about 85% exposition, and the ship’s crew are pretty interchangeable blank slates.

    But the Saxon plot inches a little further along, and Martha continues to be treated as a worthy companion, so that’s nice.

    • SpaceScotsman@startrek.website
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      3 hours ago

      I remember there was one episode of the X-Files which used camera tricks to do a near-single shot episode set on a boat. Would be ambitious, but I’m not sure it would have saved this episode.

      There was a lot of exposition, and the writing did try to explain away a lot of easy solutions to justify the episode, but it just became a bit boring by the end.