• Jesus_666@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 month ago

    Not necessarily. Germany uses just pens and paper ballots for the election and has fairly trustworthy results. We can typically call the vote after six to eight hours, with the last votes being counted within twelve.

    We do that by requiring all parties that are electable in a region to send representatives to the polling places. After voting ends, all ballots are taken to a backroom and divided into stacks. Each party representative tallies the votes in one stack, than passes the stack on to another party’s representative. They tally the stack as well; if any discrepancies are found the stack is passed on to another representative and so on. Once all ballots have been tallied and everyone agrees that the count is accurate, the ballots are put into sealed containers for secure transport to the election commission and the tally is reported to them electronically. The whole process is open to public inspection so if you want to watch people count votes for eight hours on a Sunday night you can.

    Since the count is parallelized over all polling places and over all parties within each polling place we can get authoritative results within hours. Typically, voting ends at 18:00 and the results are clear enough to call the election at around 22:00, with the last tallies coming in at around 02:00. There is no debate about manipulated voting machines because there aren’t any voting machines. And since the parties check each others# results during the count it’s assumed that the tally is fairly accurate.

    Of course that only works if you have enough parties to matter; with two parties and a talking spoiler effect you’re not going to be as fast. Oh, and in Germany polling places are only allowed to serve a certain number of voters by law; if there are too many voters and additional polling place has to be created. Of course that doesn’t mesh with the American voting district system at all.

    • MountingSuspicion@reddthat.com
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 month ago

      In general the US is able to call elections within a day. I think there are a variety of factors that make it seem like it takes longer than other places though. The US has arguably 6+ time zones, so voting may end in one place hours after another place has already counted the votes. As you mentioned, in the US there’s a variable number of voters being covered be polling stations and as of late there’s been several efforts to exacerbate that problem. We also have a rule that if you’re in line you get to vote. There have been times where lines are hours long, and that obviously can cause delays if you have a lot of people still in line even though polling has technically closed. Additionally, mail in ballots are often allowed to be posted the day of the election, so your vote might not be counted until several days after the election.

      There are of course some races that are very close and recounts are requested, but really we’re not as disorganized as the republicans would like people to believe. The “official” tally is delayed in order to ensure that people have time to question the process if needed, but that’s not a bug, it’s a feature of the system. People can definitely disagree with the system, but the Republicans acting like the delay is a problem is explicitly meant to undermine credibility for no reason among people who just don’t understand how it works.

      • BarneyPiccolo@lemmy.today
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        1 month ago

        Most votes in the USA are counted nearly immediately. By the end of the evening, we have a pretty clear picture of the in-person votes.

        The issue is the mail-in votes. Some states end their mail-on votes a week or so before Election Day, so they are all in. Other states, like California, allow mail-ins to be posted on Election Day, which means they might not arrive to be counted for a week, holding up the process.

        I’m not big on most of these “reforms” to the voting process that MAGA wants, I understand what their true agenda is, but it makes sense to demand that the mail-in votes arrive by Election Day. That’s a sensible change that would help the entire situation, and keep MAGA loudmouths quiet. It’s not a good system when we’re still waiting on a result a week after the election, especially when we’re mostly waiting on a giant state like California, while we have to listen to MAGAs torture the world with their incessant whining.

        • MountingSuspicion@reddthat.com
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          1 month ago

          Yea, I agree that we know almost immediately, I was just explaining the reason it might not seem that way. Hearing that polls closed in Florida only to know that other place have hours left can be confusing if people don’t understand how many time zones are involved. It makes people think that some states are taking the extra time to mess with votes when in reality they are just in a different time zone.

          The delay is not exclusively with mail in votes though. Certification does not happen immediately and this varies by location. Here’s a list of the rules: https://www.ncsl.org/elections-and-campaigns/election-certification-deadlines

          I don’t think anything will keep maga quiet and attempting to do anything to appease them will just result in them moving the goalposts and then once they hit a final barrier they will claim they reason you’re unwilling this time is because this is where the stealing is really happening. It’s a losing battle and we shouldn’t play.

          I don’t think voting by mail should mean they have less time or less knowledge than anyone else in their area. If something scandalous happens the day before the election you have essentially robbed them of legally being able to vote with that information. Those who vote early are exercising their right, but were likely not forced to do so, so they are at fault if they regret it later. Obviously you have to make concessions for time zones etc, but I disagree that they should have less time than their fellow constituents. I know places do things differently, but that’s my personal opinion. I think realistically these mail in votes are not holding much up, especially since the effects of the elections are months out, and a lot of it really is the certification process that varies.

        • Jesus_666@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          0
          ·
          1 month ago

          That’s a reasonable change. I definitely would encourage a reform of the voting district system, though. There is no reason for districts to exist or matter nowadays and they can be replaced by a fairly simple set of rules regarding how far polling places can be away from voters and how many there must be per X voters in the area.

    • iocase@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 month ago

      Canada does the same. Paper is extremely hard to scale an attack against and the best electronic voting machines are basically gigantic million dollar pens.

      Our method is a bit different. I worked a federal election when i was 18 and each booklet had ballots counted against the stubs. Each booklet had a serial number we had to verify against and requesting more was a whole procedure. Me and the other poll worker each counted our stack and swapped. Each party had an observer there and while we didnt need to recount i think they could requestcit if they wanted?

      Relevant Tom Scott video on why electronic voting is a terrible idea and will always be a terrible idea

    • Deckname@piefed.social
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 month ago

      Since when are votes counted by representatives of the parties?

      At least where i live(d) its always been people from the general public, not specifically sent by any party that can be voted.

      Do you have any sources for that, I’d be interested how and why this happens.

      Usually you would just make administrative staff do it, if there are not enough people willing to do it.

      • kossa@feddit.org
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        1 month ago

        its always been people from the general public

        It’s open for the general public, yes. But in a lot of places the volunteers are in a party.