Did you change thoughts or start anew?
I don’t know what you would call it.
Definitely very much an atheist.
I like humanism for the most part, but I’m not nearly as lenient as they tend to be.
Some evils deserve the absolute worst version of any possible punishment.
For example, if we had control over a literal door to a literal hell, I think we attempt to put as many backs in as possible. Obviously correctly and morally identifying them is the tricky bit to actually enforce, but once a Nazi is known, I’m more than 1,000% ok with them suffering infinitely. But Nazism is cancer to humanity, and if can’t was a conscious entity I would throw it in there too.
So “limited humanism” maybe? I don’t know what to call it, but basically all the “nice” parts of it, but being on the bad side of it is MUCH worse than the absolute “minimum suffering” goal. I want that kind of evil to suffer. If they could have enough moisture to spare enough to cry while in hell, I would steal those tears and drink them too.
Just don’t be a Nazi, Klan-level racist, or MAGA-admin-level queerphobe.
Dialectical materialism…
I’m a militant atheist.
I do challenge the claims of people knocking on my door telling me I’m going to hell or the Jesus loves me. And I ridicule their flawed reasoning.
Eastern Orthodox Christianity.
I was an atheist for most of my teens and kinda looked at neoplatonism for a bit, mainly because all the arguments for God were kinda meh at best and required bending reality to prove it. Later though I started looking at reality from a worldview based perspective, found out about the transcendental argument, read Kant, which then led me to deconstruct my worldview over the next few months and figure out that some worldview that can ground Kant’s transcendental categories must be true for me to even think. I am still not entirely sure if Eastern Orthodoxy is the only one that can do that, it’s certainly the only Christian one that can tho. Maybe some unknown worldview exists that can explain it all, no idea, but as far as known worldviews go this is the one.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Been a practicing Zen Buddhist for a few years, with an interest in eastern philosophy for longer than that. These days have raised a lot of anger in me; I treated it like a problem until I realized I had to do something with it, leading into sharpening my political philosophy and activism.
I think I heard it described as Apatheism once. Basically it absolutely doesn’t matter to me whether a god does or doesn’t exist. I already live as virtuously as is possible and if there’s a god and he dislikes that he can go fuck himself. And if there isn’t, I don’t mind just being a good person.
Why would God, the benevolent Creator who allowed for all of this to happen, dislike you being moral? The basics of many religions, including Abrahamic monotheism, involve being a righteous person. 🤷♂️
Speaking for abrahamic religions, the first few commandments are all about god being a jealous prick who doesn’t want you hanging out or thinking about other gods. The basics of most religions is control of the masses and keeping women down. Very little to do with ethical behavior.
Worshipping God (and not, say, money or yourself) and believing in the day of Judgment is the best way for everyone (because people are self-centered before anything) to act right. But, also, are we forgetting Mosaic Law? Solomon’s Ecclesiastes? Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount? 🤔
I mean, a lot of the big players today are pretty clear that nonbelievers have bad things happen to them, regardless of how nice they are.
As in in this world or in the Hereafter? Because it rains on the just and the unjust alike over here, that’s just how it is. And if you’re doing everything God wants you to do, to the best of your abilities and because of your own non-theological conviction (perhaps because you had previous negative experiences at least tangentially related to religion, like having an abusive father who used it as an excuse to act immorally, for example), why wouldn’t God in His mercy understand that as a simple “intellectual hangup” and let it slide? Are we not little emotional and confused beings after all, just trying our best if we actually care? If the sum of your deeds are pleasing to God, you’ll be fine in the Hereafter. 🤷♂️👍
Islam, for example, is pretty clear that someone who was raised Hindu, and just never converted, always goes straight to jahannam on the day of judgement. Not even the prophet’s intercession could save them.
Catholicism is a bit more nuanced. Basically, it’s easy to commit mortal sins, and it only takes one mortal sin to at least send you to purgatory, unless you become a practicing catholic. Modern evangelicals, of all kinds, agree with the Muslims. Some non-Abramic faiths have some kind of punishment for nonbelievers, as well, although it might just be a little bit of bad karma that comes out in your next life.
There’s other schools of Christianity that are closer to what you’re talking about, and, while Judaism is clear god has a favourite, the whole family is “in the will”. Both of those groups are smaller, at least as formally practiced, though.
What is conversion? If you live by God’s standards as delineated in the Qur’an, how far away are you from being a believer, even if you had some emotional and/or intellectual difficulties understanding/believing in God. Would you consider a person who claims to be Muslim, and even goes to the mosque and is called something like Abdirrahim but acts like Hell doesn’t exist and transgresses God’s limits carelessly and happily more of a believer than someone who calls themselves an atheist but “walks the narrow road” because it’s the right thing to do? Would God? You think the mentally restricted, culturally “whimsical” and somewhat unserious, and now old Western grandma who has actually really tried to be a good person (because it feels like the right thing to do) and has put the needs of others before her own constantly is just condemned to Hell because she never really got too analytical with Scripture (maybe just enough to be a casual “Abrahamic polytheist” and no more than that, and stayed sorta ideologically confused whilst still feeling and knowing being righteous and prosocial is the right thing to do)?
I’m Muslim, I’ve read the Qur’an head to toe, the mercy of God and how “those who believe in God and do good deeds” have nothing to worry about is repeated constantly. And I tell you, whatever their mouths say and whatever they might think they think, whoever does the Lord’s work is more of a believer than whoever doesn’t, regardless of what they say, and vice versa (Hegseth, Trump, some crown princes, millionaire preachers etc etc all fit this category). I’m just smart enough (thank God) to understand that many people’s so called ideologies are nothing more than superficial, shaky conjecture and the result of hurt feelings that weren’t properly analysed. Because I was there too, I’m just quicker so now I’m here and waiting for the rest, hoping and helping so they don’t get lost in the way. So, if I can see it, I’m certain God sees it too.
Idk that much about Trinitarian faiths or else I would comment on them, sorry. And thank you for the comment!
Tit for Tat strategy seems the most successful.
But other than that:
Don’t trust authorities, not your jurisdiction’s leader(s), not the rule enforcers, not your teachers, not even your parents. Always leave room to doubt everything. Accept the possibility the closest people you know are lying to you.
Well, straight tit-for-tat has a major known problem in situations that are noisy. Two players both using it end up in an infinite retaliation loop way too easily. You really want to go for a sort of merciful, “benefit of the doubt” variant, so you only go after actual enemies.
Sometimes people are just ignorant or emotionally compromised. You shouldn’t “trust” people not as much because they might knowingly scam you (some will, ofc, including most politicians), but because people are not unbiased and omniscient.
Atheist humanist, with a little sprinkle of absurdism.
I was raised in a cult (Mormonism), and easily the most crushing realization of my entire life was finding out that my entire identity as a human being–going back four generations–was based on a lie. Everything I saw about myself and the world was wrapped up in Mormon dogma.
It took a long time for me to find myself again. I had to relearn right and wrong, good and evil, and what makes life worth living. There were a couple suicide attempts in that little trip, and I’m glad I didn’t actually do it.
Human beings deserve to live. We deserve lives of dignity, meaning, and purpose–hard to do in a universe that inherently has no meaning, with short lives whose courses are dictated by arbitrary circumstances beyond our control. But all the same, if now is all we have, then now must be the most important time. There is no god, no magic, no great design that gives us a roadmap for this. So, what is the point?
The little boy tossing dying starfish back in the ocean has an answer for that. “It makes a difference to that one.” I try to live by that.
A long time ago the universe was created. This has made a lot of people angry and is widely regarded as a bad idea.
This is funny.
That’s because it’s from a great book from a great author that I haven’t read
Discworld! I’ve only read excerpts, but his style is so recognizable.When I looked it up, I saw the quote
In the beginning there was nothing, which exploded.
Attributed to him, and I guess just… didn’t read the whole thing? So I assumed “yep, my memory is right, now I get to post confidently!”
Gosh do I ever love being proven wrong after “double checking” my work.
Terry Pratchett’s writing is still brilliant and hilarious, but that’s not directly relevant here.
I should still get around to actually reading Discworld…
Even if that’s not relevant to this.
Close, it’s from The Restaurant at the End of the Universe by Douglas Adams.
Thank you for the correction! I can’t believe I’ve done this.
We exist, for no particular reason, except by chain of cause and effect. We’ve been incredibly lucky to be here, so far as we can tell. There is no meaning to life, as it’s a genuine gift of the universe. That way your life can be anything you choose it to be. In this way, the universe is bigger than any attempt to make sense of it. I don’t dislike religion because god or whatever, it’s just boring and simple minded. It lets go of the true beauty of the universe so you can have something in return. I wouldn’t trade my way of seeing the universe for death, or anyone…
“I don’t believe in anything, but I have many suspicions.” --Robert Anton Wilson
I One should strive to act with compassion and empathy toward all creatures in accordance with reason. II The struggle for justice is an ongoing and necessary pursuit that should prevail over laws and institutions. III One’s body is inviolable, subject to one’s own will alone. IV The freedoms of others should be respected, including the freedom to offend. To willfully and unjustly encroach upon the freedoms of another is to forgo one's own. V Beliefs should conform to one's best scientific understanding of the world. One should take care never to distort scientific facts to fit one's beliefs. VI People are fallible. If one makes a mistake, one should do one's best to rectify it and resolve any harm that might have been caused. VII Every tenet is a guiding principle designed to inspire nobility in action and thought. The spirit of compassion, wisdom, and justice should always prevail over the written or spoken word.These are the Seven Tenets of Satanism, and I do my best to live by them. I’m not perfect, but so long as I’m better than who I was the day before, we’re doing alright.
Was Satanism just a tongue in cheek criticism of nonsensical, immoral Trinitarian behaviour/beliefs (like “don’t do shit, Jesus died for your sins already so behave as you want”)? Because it sounds like it, and very Jesus-like ofc, lol.
Be honest and treat people how you’d like to be treated.
“What would Captain Picard do?”
Drink tea?
I do drink Earl Grey and I started because of JLP.









